Police Confessions Without Real Miranda Warnings Cannot Convict the Accused

Police admissions during custodial investigation cannot convict unless rights were clearly explained and validly waived; conviction was reversed. A confession taken during police questioning is not enough to convict an accused person unless the prosecution proves that the suspect was clearly informed of the right to remain silent, the right to counsel, and the consequences […]

Military Trial After Martial Law? The Supreme Court Says Civil Courts Take Over

Civilians cannot remain before a military tribunal after martial law when no valid arraignment gave it jurisdiction; prosecution must move to civil courts. When martial law ends, civilians cannot be kept indefinitely before military tribunals merely because a case began there. If the military body never validly acquired jurisdiction before its authority ended, the case […]

Confessions Without Counsel Cannot Convict: Why Galit Still Protects Suspects Under Custodial Investigation

Confessions taken without meaningful counsel and clear rights warnings are inadmissible; Galit’s conviction was reversed for custodial rights violations. A confession taken from a suspect without meaningful access to counsel is not merely weak evidence; it is inadmissible evidence. For persons accused of crimes, People v. Galit is a stark reminder that police shortcuts during […]

When a Court Must Open the Ballot Boxes: The Recount Right in Election Protests

The Court held that election protestants may obtain ballot revision without first proving irregularities when recount rules apply. A losing candidate who files a proper election protest may be entitled to a recount of the ballots even without first proving fraud, irregularity, or misappreciation of votes. The practical doctrine is simple but powerful: when the […]

Why Employees Can Be Taxed Differently From Professionals and Business Owners

Employees may be taxed differently from professionals and business owners if Congress uses reasonable classifications and applies them uniformly within each class. Taxpayers cannot defeat an income tax law merely by showing that employees, professionals, and business owners are not taxed in exactly the same way. When Congress creates tax brackets or separates classes of […]

Tourism Public Use Doctrine: Eminent Domain for Development

Private land may be expropriated for tourism development when public use, necessity, and just compensation exist, with courts deferring to policy in PH. The Tourism Public Use Doctrine confirms that private land may be taken by eminent domain for a government tourism development project when the taking serves public welfare and just compensation is paid. […]

Candidate Due Process Rule: Charges Cannot Bar Election Runs

Election candidates cannot be disqualified by mere charges; due process requires proof, and constitutional suits need actual injury before courts act in the Philippines. The Candidate Due Process Rule protects candidates from being removed from an election race merely because someone filed criminal or misconduct charges against them. For candidates, political parties, and voters, Dumlao […]

Bare Constitutional Attacks Will Not Overturn a Conviction When the Evidence Is Sufficient

A criminal appeal failed where constitutional objections were foreclosed by precedent and multiple witnesses supported the trial court’s factual findings. A criminal appeal cannot succeed on constitutional slogans alone when the prosecution has proved the required acts through competent witnesses and the accused has chosen not to present contrary evidence. In Alejandrino, the Supreme Court […]

Just Compensation Valuation: When Expropriation Value Is Fixed

Just compensation is valued at filing when no prior taking occurred; assessed value and deposits do not cap fair market value in expropriation. Just compensation valuation follows the filing-date rule when the government has not yet taken the property before filing an expropriation case. For property owners, this means the State cannot depress compensation by […]