Coerced Confessions Cannot Convict: Why Courts Must Exclude Evidence Obtained Through Force

A coerced confession cannot convict an accused. The Court excluded doubtful confessions, affirmed two convictions, and acquitted two others on reasonable doubt. A confession extracted through force, threat, intimidation, or custodial pressure cannot be used to send a person to prison. People v. Guillermo is a reminder that criminal convictions must rest on reliable, independent […]

When a Criminal Law Challenge Becomes Moot: Why Courts Will Not Decide Academic Questions

A released accused could not continue an abstract constitutional challenge after prosecution ended, reinforcing the live controversy rule in enforcement disputes. A constitutional challenge can disappear before the court reaches the merits when the accused has already been released and the prosecution has ceased. For persons facing criminal proceedings, including business owners or officers dealing […]

A Guilty Plea Is Not a Shortcut to Conviction: Why Courts Must Still Test the Evidence in Capital Cases

A guilty plea in a capital case does not end judicial scrutiny; courts must still examine evidence, intent, aggravating circumstances, and penalty. A person who pleads guilty to a capital offense is not automatically condemned by that plea alone. Courts must still receive evidence, determine whether the accused understood the charge and consequences, examine aggravating […]

You Cannot Be Convicted of Murder When the Charge Only Says Homicide

An accused charged only with homicide cannot be convicted of murder unless the qualifying circumstance is alleged in the information. A person accused of homicide cannot be sentenced for murder unless the facts that legally make the killing murder are clearly alleged in the criminal information. The constitutional right to be informed of the nature […]

A Guilty Plea in a Murder Case Does Not End the Courtโ€™s Duty to Test the Evidence

A guilty plea in murder must still be tested by evidence, especially where confessions, aggravating circumstances, and severe penalties are involved. Even when an accused admits guilt in open court, a judge must still proceed with exceptional care in serious criminal cases: the plea may support conviction, but the record must show that the accused […]

When Government Delay Makes a Case Moot: Why Mandamus Requires a Live Controversy

Mandamus against a government agency may be dismissed when later events remove the live controversy, even if the original refusal raised constitutional issues. A person asking the courts to compel a government agency to act must still have a live, practical dispute by the time the case is decided; if the facts that gave rise […]

Rent Control Can Stop Ejectment Even When the Lease Has Expired

Rent-control legislation may suspend ejectment based on lease expiration, and police power can override ordinary contract remedies in housing disputes. Landlords cannot use an expired lease term alone to eject residential occupants when rent-control legislation has suspended that very ground for ejectment. In Gutierrez v. Cantada, the controlling lesson is a police-power doctrine with direct […]

Habeas Corpus Still Matters When Customs Enforcement Leads to Detention Without Charges

Habeas corpus may challenge detention without charges, but release or court commitment can moot the remedy while leaving officials exposed to scrutiny. People detained in customs, smuggling, or tax-enforcement investigations may use habeas corpus to force the government to justify the restraint, but the remedy can become moot once the person is released or placed […]

Clergy Office Ban: Priests Cannot Be Municipal Mayors

Priests and ministers remain disqualified from municipal office; the clergy office ban survives as a church-state safeguard in Philippine election law. The clergy office ban means that religious office-holders may be barred from occupying municipal public office, not because they are punished for their faith, but because Philippine constitutional law permits safeguards that preserve the […]