The Supreme Court upheld the DOJ’s 2024 preliminary investigation rules, allowing prosecutors to require prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction.
People facing criminal complaints before prosecutors may now invoke a more demanding screening standard at the preliminary investigation stage: the DOJ’s 2024 rules requiring prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction remain valid, and prosecutors may assess not merely whether a case can be filed, but whether the available evidence can realistically sustain a conviction if left uncontradicted.
Why This Matters to Businesses, Taxpayers, and Individuals Under Investigation
The ruling matters because preliminary investigation is often the first decisive battleground in criminal exposure. For business owners, corporate officers, accountants, tax managers, and individuals named in criminal complaints, the case confirms that the prosecutor’s office is not required to act as a mere forwarding station for weak complaints. Under the 2024 DOJ-NPS Rules, prosecutors are directed to look at whether the evidence at hand is admissible, credible, capable of preservation, and capable of proving all elements of the alleged offense and the identity of the persons responsible.
For tax-related disputes that may involve possible criminal referral, such as alleged fraudulent returns, withholding tax violations, falsification, or other revenue-linked offenses, the practical point is straightforward: the preliminary investigation stage can be used to attack the sufficiency, admissibility, credibility, and presentation value of the evidence before the case reaches court. The ruling does not create a tax doctrine, but it has clear relevance for taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal prosecution risk because it confirms the DOJ’s authority to set prosecutorial standards for preliminary investigations and inquest proceedings.
Background: A Challenge to the DOJ’s 2024 Prosecutorial Rules
Atty. Hazel L. Meking challenged Department Circular No. 015, issued by the Secretary of Justice, which contains the 2024 Department of Justice–National Prosecution Service Rules on Preliminary Investigations and Inquest Proceedings. The challenged rule states that the quantum of evidence in preliminary investigations and inquest proceedings is prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction. The case reached the Supreme Court as Meking v. Remulla (G.R. No. 280455, November 11, 2025).
The petitioner argued that, by changing the evidentiary threshold from the familiar probable cause formulation under Rule 112 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, the Department of Justice intruded into the Supreme Court’s exclusive constitutional power to promulgate rules on pleading, practice, and procedure in all courts. The central question was institutional: who controls the rules for preliminary investigation when that process sits at the boundary between prosecution and court procedure?
The Supreme Court’s Answer: Preliminary Investigation Is Executive, Not Judicial
The Supreme Court dismissed the petition and upheld Department Circular No. 015. The Court reasoned that the matter had already been addressed in its earlier resolution concerning the draft DOJ-NPS rules, where it recognized the authority of the Department of Justice to issue rules governing preliminary investigations and inquest proceedings. The Court emphasized that preliminary investigation is not a judicial function. It is an executive function performed by prosecutors as part of the prosecutorial process.
That distinction carried the ruling. Because the DOJ-NPS Rules regulate the conduct of prosecutors before a case is filed in court, they do not dictate court practice or court procedure. The Supreme Court’s rule-making power remains supreme over judicial proceedings, but the DOJ may regulate how prosecutors evaluate complaints, evidence, counter-affidavits, and the sufficiency of the case before deciding whether to file an information.
The Doctrine: Executive Screening Standard for Criminal Complaints
The doctrine may be called the Executive Screening Standard for Criminal Complaints. It recognizes that prosecutors may be required to conduct a deeper evidence-based review before filing a criminal case, so long as the rule governs prosecutorial action and not court procedure. The DOJ may require prosecutors to determine whether the evidence establishes a prima facie case with reasonable certainty of conviction, including whether the evidence can prove all elements of the offense and identify the responsible persons.
This is more demanding than a purely mechanical view of probable cause. The prosecutor must consider the entirety of the evidence, including the respondent’s counter-affidavit, and evaluate whether the evidence is admissible, credible, and capable of being preserved and presented. The ruling therefore gives respondents a meaningful framework for arguing that a complaint should be dismissed at the preliminary investigation stage because the evidence cannot realistically support conviction.
What Did Not Change: Courts Still Protect Constitutional Rights
The ruling does not make prosecutors immune from judicial review. The Supreme Court expressly preserved its power to correct prosecutorial rules or actions that amount to grave abuse of discretion or impair constitutional rights. This matters for respondents who may still challenge a prosecutor’s action through the proper remedy when the prosecutor acts arbitrarily, ignores material evidence, or applies the rules in a way that violates due process.
The ruling also does not transfer court procedure to the Department of Justice. Once a criminal case is filed in court, the judiciary’s constitutional rule-making power governs judicial proceedings. The DOJ rule operates within the executive sphere: the screening and evaluation of criminal complaints before court litigation begins.
Practical Impact for Respondents in Criminal and Tax-Related Investigations
For respondents, the decision reinforces the importance of treating the counter-affidavit as a serious evidentiary pleading, not as a perfunctory denial. A respondent should challenge each element of the alleged offense, identify inadmissible or unreliable documents, contest weak witness statements, and explain why the evidence cannot be preserved or presented in a form capable of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
For corporate officers and taxpayers, this means early defense strategy matters. When a complaint alleges a criminal violation connected with business operations, accounting records, tax filings, corporate acts, or documentary submissions, the defense should be built around the DOJ’s own screening language: admissibility, credibility, preservation, presentation, proof of all elements, and identification of the responsible person. These are not abstract concepts. They are now embedded in the valid prosecutorial standard upheld by the Court.
For complainants, the ruling is equally important. A criminal complaint must be prepared as if the prosecutor will ask whether the evidence can actually sustain conviction. Bare accusations, incomplete documents, unclear authorship, weak authentication, or speculative links to a corporate officer may no longer be enough under the DOJ’s screening framework. Complainants must present evidence that is organized, admissible, credible, and tied to every element of the offense.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, taxpayers, corporate officers, professionals, and individuals involved in criminal, tax-related, regulatory, and commercial disputes. We assist clients in preparing counter-affidavits, responding to subpoenas, evaluating criminal exposure, challenging weak complaints, and building early-stage defense strategies before prosecutors and courts.
If you or your company is facing a preliminary investigation, tax-related criminal complaint, corporate fraud allegation, or DOJ proceeding, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our litigation and tax controversy team. Early legal strategy can determine whether a case is dismissed before trial or allowed to become a full criminal prosecution.