Corporate Appeals Can Fail When the Wrong Person Signs for the Company

A corporate appeal may fail if filed without valid authority or a proper anti-forum shopping certification, even before courts reach the merits. A corporation, association, or business organization can lose an appeal before the Supreme Court without any review of the merits if the petition is filed by persons who lack authority to act for […]

Tax Refund Fairness Rule: When BIR Must Return Excess Taxes

Valid tax refund claims cannot be defeated by technicalities when records prove excess withholding taxes were paid and not properly retained. The Tax Refund Fairness Rule protects taxpayers from losing valid refund claims because of avoidable technical objections after the taxpayer has already submitted the documents needed to prove excess withholding taxes. For corporations, property […]

RMC No. 36-2007: PEZA Incentives for Special Economic Zones Inside the Clark Freeport Zone

RMC No. 36-2007 confirms PEZA-administered tax and duty incentives for registered enterprises in proclaimed special economic zones inside Clark Freeport. Businesses planning to operate inside special economic zones within the Clark Freeport Zone must determine whether their location has been specifically created by Presidential proclamation and whether their enterprise must register with the Philippine Economic […]

Zero-Rated VAT Refund Doctrine: When Invoice Defects Do Not Defeat Claims

Zero-rated exporters may recover input VAT when statutory proof exists; invoice defects not required by law cannot defeat valid refund claims. The Zero-Rated VAT Refund Doctrine protects qualified exporters from losing valid input VAT refund or tax credit claims merely because export sales invoices omit details that the Tax Code did not require to be […]

When Stockholders Can Sue Directors but Still Lose: The Business Judgment Shield in Corporate Mismanagement Cases

Stockholders may file derivative suits for corporate injury, but directors are not liable for board decisions absent proof of bad faith, malice, fraud, or loss. Corporate directors are not personally liable merely because a stockholder disagrees with their hiring, compensation, or management decisions. A derivative suit may allow a shareholder to sue on behalf of […]

Majority Stockholders Can Remove Directorsβ€”But Corporate Officers Can Be Removed by the Board

The Court upheld board removal of corporate officers and stockholder removal of directors, clarifying voting and procedure rules in corporate control disputes. Corporate control disputes often turn on one practical rule: directors and officers are not removed in the same way. A corporate officer may be discharged by the board that appointed the officer, while […]

When Informal Payments Are Not Salary: Lessons on Stock Sales, Donations, and Corporate Records

A shareholder who accepted full payment could not undo a stock sale despite irregular records; informal salary claims may be treated as void donations. Corporate shareholders cannot use irregular stock-transfer paperwork to undo a sale they knowingly accepted, especially after receiving the full purchase price and allowing the transaction to stand for years. For business […]

Accrual Deduction Rule: When Tax Expenses Must Be Claimed

Accrual-basis taxpayers must deduct fixed, reasonably determinable expenses in the proper taxable year, not when later billed. Accrual-basis taxpayers cannot wait for a bill before claiming a deductible business expense if the liability was already fixed and reasonably determinable in an earlier taxable year. Under the Accrual Deduction All-Events Rule, professional fees for legal and […]

When Corporate Elections Are Contested, the SEC May Still Act

A corporate election case does not stop the SEC from exercising retained regulatory powers, and election contests must be filed within 15 days. A pending corporate election dispute does not automatically freeze all regulatory action involving the corporation. Stockholders and directors fighting over control may go to court over the validity of meetings, elections, or […]