Late SEC Appeals Can End Investment Recovery Cases Before the Merits Are Reopened

Late SEC appeals may fail under either old or new rules, while officers may be personally liable if they assented to unlawful corporate acts. Parties who lose before an administrative hearing officer cannot preserve their appeal by mixing old and new procedural rules, especially where one rule treats a motion for reconsideration as prohibited and […]

Foreclosed Property Repurchase Offers Do Not Create a Sale Until the Bank Clearly Accepts

A deposit and bank negotiations did not create a perfected sale of foreclosed property because PNB never gave unconditional acceptance of Manila Metal’s terms. A former owner who wants to buy back foreclosed property cannot rely on negotiations, deposits, internal bank recommendations, or proposed payment terms unless there is a clear, unconditional meeting of minds […]

When a Company Name Does Not Shield a Trader Who Personally Received the Goods

A trader who personally received imported goods was held liable, while the corporation was absolved absent proof it authorized or assumed the obligation. A person who personally receives imported goods and undertakes to dispose of them cannot avoid liability merely by pointing to a company name, especially when the evidence shows that the person, not […]

When a Tax Franchise Lets a Company Choose the Lower Tax Burden

Special franchise taxpayers may choose the lower tax option when the law allows it, and PAL’s choice exempted it from final withholding tax. A taxpayer holding a special legislative franchise may, when the franchise so provides, choose between the regular corporate income tax and the franchise tax, and the choice can eliminate liability for taxes […]

Gross Receipts Tax Rule: Why Withheld Tax Still Counts

Final withholding tax on bank interest remains part of gross receipts; banks cannot deduct it from the gross receipts tax base without law. The gross receipts tax rule for banks is unforgiving: final withholding tax deducted from passive interest income still forms part of taxable gross receipts because the bank is treated as having received […]

When Does the Four-Year MCIT Grace Period Start for a Thrift Bank?

A thrift bank’s MCIT grace period starts from the later of SEC registration or BSP authority, making premature MCIT payments refundable. A thrift bank does not become liable for minimum corporate income tax merely because it previously existed as a different kind of bank or remained registered with the BIR. For thrift banks, the four-year […]

When Corporate Officers Borrow Without Board Authority: Why Companies Are Not Automatically Bound by Their President’s Loans

A corporate president’s loan did not bind the company absent board authority or valid ratification, and a mortgage over corporate land failed for lack of authority. A corporation is not automatically liable for money borrowed by its president merely because the president used the corporate title, signed promissory notes, or later placed the money into […]

When a Corporate Officer Signs Without Board Authority: Why the Company May Not Be Bound

Corporate officers cannot bind a corporation without board authority or ratification; courts also require competent proof before imposing counterclaim liability. A corporation is not automatically bound by a loan, promissory note, or financial undertaking merely because its president, chairman, or other officer signed the document. The party seeking to enforce the obligation must prove that […]

When Dead Members No Longer Count: The Quorum Rule for Nonstock Corporations

Nonstock corporations compute quorum from actual voting members, not deceased members, helping nonprofits validate elections and avoid governance paralysis. Nonstock corporations, including schools, foundations, churches, associations, and other tax-exempt or nonprofit organizations, may determine quorum based on their actual living members with voting rights when deceased members have ceased to be members under the corporation’s […]

When Asset Transfers Do Not Escape Old Debts: The Creditor Protection Rule in Corporate Restructuring

Asset buyers may answer for assumed business debts when substantially all assets are transferred and creditor claims would otherwise be defeated. A company that acquires substantially all of another company’s business assets may also inherit the practical burden of that company’s existing obligations, especially when the transfer agreement says the buyer will assume claims, pending […]