Idle Corporate Surplus Can Trigger Accumulated Earnings Tax Even When Profits Were Earned Years Earlier

Corporations may face accumulated earnings tax when retained profits exceed real business needs, even if the surplus came from prior years. Corporations cannot avoid shareholder-level income tax by parking profits in investments and later claiming that the money might someday be used for expansion. When corporate earnings are accumulated beyond the reasonable and immediate needs […]

Mining Tax Exemptions Do Not Automatically Cover Withholding Taxes on Interest Income

Mining tax exemptions did not cover withholding tax on lenders’ interest income; the Supreme Court denied the company’s refund claim. A mining company that enjoys statutory tax exemptions cannot assume that every tax connected to its financing is covered. When borrowed funds earn interest before they are used, the withholding tax on that interest remains […]

Foreign Companies Without Philippine Licenses Can Still Enforce Contracts in Court After Compliance

Foreign companies may enforce contracts after compliance; lack of a Philippine license affects capacity to sue, not automatic contract validity. A foreign corporation’s failure to secure a Philippine license before doing business does not automatically make its contracts void. For businesses, insurers, carriers, and taxpayers dealing with cross-border transactions, the consequence is important: the penalty […]

Buying One Share Does Not Open a Bank’s Books: Good Faith Limits on Stockholder Inspection Rights

A one-share stockholder cannot inspect bank records without good faith, legitimate purpose, and compliance with special charter confidentiality limits. A stockholder’s right to inspect corporate records is powerful, but it is not a license to buy a token share merely to investigate past transactions, gather litigation material, or pry into confidential bank affairs unrelated to […]

Lost Stock Certificates Are Not Ordinary Civil Claims: Why Stockholders Must Bring Replacement Disputes to the Corporate Forum

A stockholder’s claim for replacement of a missing stock certificate is an intra-corporate controversy, and damages do not move it to ordinary courts. Stockholders who are refused a replacement stock certificate cannot automatically turn that dispute into an ordinary damages case in the regular courts. When the controversy is fundamentally between a stockholder and the […]

Tax Deductions Fail When Bonuses Look Like Profit Distributions, Not Payment for Services

Officer profit-sharing bonuses were not deductible without proof of services, and late tax-exemption claims could not defeat a BIR deficiency assessment. Corporate taxpayers cannot convert profit-sharing payments to officers into deductible business expenses merely by calling them bonuses. When a claimed deduction is not tied to actual personal services, and when a tax-exemption theory is […]

When Tax Deductions Survive BIR Challenge: Atlas and the Business Expense Rule for Corporate Taxpayers

Atlas clarifies when corporate expenses are deductible, allowing investor and listing-related costs but treating title-defense litigation expenses as capital costs. Corporate taxpayers may deduct expenses that genuinely serve the business even when the benefit is indirect, reputational, or investor-facing, but they cannot turn capital-preserving litigation costs into ordinary deductions. The Atlas ruling remains important because […]

Tax Deductions Are Not Won by Labels: What Atlas Teaches Companies About Proving Business Expenses

Atlas clarifies when corporate expenses are deductible, capital, or disallowed, stressing proof, business purpose, and proper issue-raising in tax appeals. A company cannot deduct an expense from taxable income merely because it was paid in connection with its business. The taxpayer must prove that the expense was ordinary, necessary, paid or incurred during the taxable […]

When There Is No Tax Return to File, the BIR’s Assessment Period May Not Run

The Supreme Court held that no ordinary prescription period barred BIR assessment of the 25% surtax where no return was required for the tax. Corporations cannot assume that every tax assessment becomes void after the ordinary limitation period. Where the tax law requires no return for the particular tax involved, the Supreme Court held that […]