No Time Limit Without a Tax Prescription Law: What Ayala Securities Means for Accumulated Earnings Tax Assessments

The Court held that the 25% surtax on improperly accumulated surplus was not barred by the ordinary assessment period absent a clear prescription law. Corporate taxpayers cannot assume that every tax assessment becomes invalid after the ordinary assessment period. When the tax law imposes a liability but does not provide a clear prescriptive period for […]

When a Family Corporation Is Treated as an Estate: Piercing the Corporate Veil in Property and Tax Disputes

Family corporations may lose separate personality when used as an alter ego to hold estate assets, allowing heirs to pursue partition despite corporate title. A corporation’s separate personality will not protect a family property arrangement when the company is merely the alter ego of the deceased owner and recognizing the corporate fiction would defeat inheritance, […]

When Shareholder Settlements Do Not Kill Corporate Fraud Claims

A shareholder settlement did not waive claims against non-settling directors, and courts may review stock issuances alleged to oppress minority shareholders. Corporate insiders cannot defeat a shareholder challenge simply by pointing to a partial settlement with other defendants or by calling a contested stock issuance a matter of internal management. Where the transaction allegedly injures […]

Foreign Companies Recruiting Filipinos Cannot Hide Behind an Offshore Address

Foreign companies recruiting Filipinos through local representatives may be treated as doing business and sued in Philippine courts for labor claims. Foreign companies that use the Philippines as a place to recruit Filipino workers, maintain a local representative, or carry out recurring business-related acts may be treated as doing business here—and may be sued here […]

Dissolving a Partnership Does Not Make Its Assets Judgment-Proof

Dissolved partnerships may still face collection against business assets during winding up, and courts cannot void another branch’s final judgment by collateral suit. Business owners cannot defeat creditors merely by dissolving a partnership, shifting assets through a chattel mortgage, or asking another court branch to undo a prior final judgment. Where the business continues in […]

When a Tax Assessment Comes Too Late: Prescription Can Defeat the BIR’s 25% Surtax on Accumulated Profits

A late BIR assessment for accumulated surplus was cancelled because prescription had set in, and fraud could not be presumed to extend the assessment period. A corporation may defeat a tax assessment when the BIR acts beyond the legally allowed assessment period, even if the government later insists that the corporation improperly accumulated profits to […]

When Stock Certificates Are Frozen by the SEC, Documentary Stamp Tax May Have to Wait

The Supreme Court held that SEC-restricted stock certificates are not yet subject to documentary stamp tax until shareholders can exercise ownership rights. Corporations do not automatically owe documentary stamp tax on every stock certificate merely because it has been printed or deposited with a regulator. For documentary stamp tax on an original issue of stock […]

When Stock Dividends Become Taxable Income

Stock dividends may become taxable when treasury shares shift corporate value to insiders, especially where earnings fund a buy-out and increase ownership. Corporate officers and shareholders cannot avoid income tax by labeling a transaction as a stock dividend when, in substance, corporate earnings are being used to give them a measurable economic benefit. The Manning […]

Treasury Stock Dividends Can Become Taxable Income When They Function Like a Cash Distribution

Treasury stock dividends may be taxable when they distribute accumulated earnings and increase shareholders’ economic interests, despite corporate labels. Corporate taxpayers cannot avoid income tax merely by labeling a distribution as a stock dividend when, in substance, the transaction releases accumulated corporate earnings to selected shareholders and increases their economic interest in the company. For […]