The CTA upheld Makati City’s LBT assessment for Takenaka Corporation, confirming procedural and documentation requirements. Prior payments and protest arguments were insufficient to void the NOA.
Businesses operating in multiple jurisdictions must carefully allocate their tax obligations to avoid double taxation, as highlighted by the recent Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) decision affecting Takenaka Corporation – Philippine Branch. The Court confirmed that the City of Makati’s local business tax (LBT) assessment for taxable years 2013 to 2017 remains valid, emphasizing strict adherence to documentation and procedural rules for tax protests.
Background
Takenaka Corporation, a foreign-owned entity engaged in infrastructure projects in the Philippines, challenged the City of Makati’s LBT assessment totaling P25,767,396.84. The assessment, covering 2013 to 2017, included surcharges and interest. Takenaka argued that revenues recognized in prior years (2001-2003) were already taxed and thus should not be included, and that the situs of sales allocation between Makati and Pasay was improperly applied. (CTA AC No. 307)
Previously, the Regional Trial Court denied Takenaka’s protest and motion for reconsideration, finding insufficient proof of prior LBT payments. Takenaka claimed compliance through financial statements, tax returns, business permits, and certifications from Pasay City, asserting that the absence of receipts for payments beyond the statutory retention period should not prejudice it.
CTA Ruling
The CTA affirmed that the Court had jurisdiction over the review of local tax cases under Section 7(a)(3) of RA 1125, as amended, and Section 3(a)(3) of Rule 4 of the Revised Rules of the CTA. On the merits, the Court emphasized that tax assessments enjoy a presumption of correctness, and the burden of proof lies with the taxpayer. Takenaka’s evidence, while demonstrating past payments and allocation practices, failed to establish actual payment to Makati City for the revenues recognized in 2001-2003.
The CTA also noted that the reversal of previously recorded doubtful accounts, write-offs, and recognition of other operating income for 2001-2003 were properly excluded from taxable gross sales for 2013-2017, but the taxpayer did not adequately substantiate these claims with official receipts. The Court held that procedural requirements, including payment under protest per Makati City Revenue Code and LGC Section 195, were properly enforced, and the NOA was valid.
Key Legal Principles Applied
1. Tax assessments by local government examiners are presumed correct; taxpayers bear the burden of proof to challenge them.
2. LBT allocation must respect the situs of sales, with the principal office’s location affecting Makati’s tax share.
3. The percentage of completion method used for financial reporting does not automatically exempt income from current-year LBT.
4. Retention periods govern the admissibility of official receipts; unavailability of documents beyond statutory retention does not relieve taxpayer of the burden to substantiate payment.
5. Payment under protest requirements under local ordinances remain enforceable, consistent with LGC rules.
Practical Takeaways
Companies operating in multiple LGUs must carefully track payment and documentation for LBT to prevent assessments and disputes. Relying on past payments or certifications from other jurisdictions is insufficient without proper official receipts and adherence to procedural requirements. Taxpayers should also understand that local ordinances mandating payment under protest before contesting assessments remain enforceable, and the CTA will defer to such procedural compliance.
For similarly situated taxpayers, this decision underscores the importance of maintaining clear records of prior payments, understanding local situs rules, and following statutory protest procedures. Disputes over allocation or historical revenue recognition require concrete evidence to succeed in administrative or judicial appeals.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Our tax litigation team guides businesses through local and national tax disputes, including LBT, VAT, and income tax controversies. We assist in documenting payments, structuring protests, and representing clients before the CTA and local government units. Visit