When Listed Shares Are Sold Through the Stock Exchange, Corporations Cannot Block Registration Without Good Cause

Fully paid buyers of listed shares may compel registration; sequestration alone does not make shares government-owned, and stock exchange sales may satisfy bidding concerns. Fully paid buyers of listed shares have a enforceable right to registration in the corporation’s stock and transfer books, and a corporation cannot refuse transfer merely by raising unresolved doubts about […]

Corporate Settlements Can End Litigation Even After Submission for Decision

The Supreme Court allowed withdrawal after settlement and denied intervention by a former counsel with only a contingent corporate interest. Corporate litigants who have resolved their boardroom dispute may ask the court to end the case even after it has been submitted for resolution, and a former lawyer or corporate officer cannot keep the lawsuit […]

A Court Order Is Not Enough: Why Injunction Bonds Can Decide Corporate Control Fights

The Supreme Court held that a preliminary injunction needs a timely bond before it can stop a corporate share sale or support contempt claims. A party trying to stop a disputed corporate share sale must do more than obtain an order saying the sale should be enjoined; the required injunction bond must be filed and […]

Tax Refund Claims Fail Without Payor-Issued Withholding Certificates

Taxpayers claiming creditable withholding tax refunds must present payor-issued proof linking the withholding to specific income payments and transactions. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit for creditable withholding tax must prove not only that tax was withheld, but that the withholding is traceable to a specific payor, income payment, and transaction. A taxpayer’s own […]

When the BIR Waits Too Long: Tax Assessments Can Expire Even After They Are Issued

A timely BIR assessment can still become uncollectible if collection is filed too late; ordinary reconsideration protests do not suspend prescription. A tax assessment does not give the BIR an unlimited time to collect. Even if the government validly issues an assessment before the deadline, the right to collect that assessed deficiency tax can still […]

When Corporate Asset Sales Go Wrong: Property Recovery Cases Belong in Court, Not the SEC

The Supreme Court held that a corporation’s property recovery suit against a receiver’s alleged unauthorized sale belongs in the RTC, not the SEC. A corporation that seeks to recover real property allegedly sold without authority by its rehabilitation receiver may file an ordinary court action for reconveyance, annulment of sale, and damages; the dispute does […]

When a Corporate Officer Files Without Board Authority, the Case Can Be Dismissed

A corporation’s petition may be dismissed when signed by an officer without board authority, even if the officer was involved in the underlying dispute. A corporation cannot ask a court to undo an adverse ruling through an officer who was never shown to be authorized by its board. For companies facing labor, tax, regulatory, or […]

When a Government Board Cannot Perpetuate Itself: The Supreme Court’s Rule on Appointments in Public Corporations

The Supreme Court held that a government corporation board cannot fill its own trustee vacancies when doing so violates presidential appointment power. Government corporations cannot use their charters to create self-perpetuating boards when the Constitution reserves appointment power to the President or to constitutionally recognized appointing authorities. For public officers, trustees, and regulated entities dealing […]