When the Ombudsman Cannot Investigate GOCC Officers: The Original Charter Rule for Government-Controlled Corporations

Government shareholding alone does not make corporate officers public officers; Ombudsman jurisdiction over GOCCs depends on an original charter. Corporate officers of a government-controlled company are not automatically within the Ombudsmanโ€™s disciplinary and prosecutorial reach merely because the government owns or controls the corporation. The decisive question is narrower: was the corporation created by a […]

Mining Permits Cannot Be Sold, Assigned, or Revived by Corporate Structure Alone

Mining permits cannot be revived or assigned through corporate structure alone; invalid transfers and expired permits do not create enforceable mineral rights. A mining permit that has expired, or that was transferred without the required government approval, cannot be revived by calling the transferee an affiliate, subsidiary, agent, or successor. For mining companies, investors, financiers, […]

Sequestered Shares Do Not Automatically Lose Voting Rights

Registered owners of sequestered shares keep voting rights unless the government proves a clear legal basis to restrain them. Registered shareholders whose assets are under government sequestration do not automatically lose the right to vote their shares. Unless the government can show a clear legal right to injunctive relief, sequestration preserves property while ownership is […]

When a Former Lawyer Uses Your Corporate Records Against You

A lawyer may be disciplined for using client information in later corporate disputes, even if he claims to act as a stockholder or insider. A lawyer who turns client confidences into weapons for later disputes can be disciplined even if the lawyer also claims to be acting as a stockholder or corporate insider. The core […]

When Corporate Fraud Allegations Can Lead to Arrest Before Trial

Probable cause, not proof beyond reasonable doubt, is enough for a warrant of arrest in corporate fraud and syndicated estafa cases. A person accused in an investment or corporate fraud case cannot defeat a warrant of arrest by demanding that the judge first conduct a mini-trial on guilt. If the prosecution records show facts that […]

When Courts May Take Over Corporate Books: The Sy Chim Rule on Emergency Audits and Management Committees

Courts may order an independent audit in corporate disputes, but cannot impose a management committee without clear imminent danger to assets. Corporate officers accused of withholding records or mishandling company funds may be subjected to an emergency court-supervised audit even before the main case is decided, but courts cannot immediately take over corporate management unless […]

Calling an Employee a Corporate Officer Will Not Remove Labor Court Jurisdiction

The Court held that job titles alone do not make an employee a corporate officer, and loss of confidence requires proof plus due process. Companies cannot defeat an illegal dismissal case simply by calling a dismissed employee a corporate officer. Unless the position is created by the corporationโ€™s charter or by-laws, and unless the employer […]

Tax Refunds Follow the Statute, Not Later Tax Increases

Tax refunds must follow the exact statute granting them; later tax increases do not enlarge refund claims absent clear legislative authority. Taxpayers claiming a statutory refund cannot enlarge that refund by using later tax rates unless the law clearly says so. In CDCP Mining, the Supreme Court applied a practical but strict rule for tax […]

When a Corporate Officer Faces a Criminal Case, the Victim Can Still Pursue Civil Damages Inside the Same Trial

The Supreme Court allowed private prosecutors to intervene in a corporate falsification case because civil liability was deemed included in the criminal action. A person harmed by alleged corporate falsification may pursue the civil consequences of the crime within the criminal case itself, unless that civil action was waived, reserved, or already filed separately. The […]