You Cannot Pierce the Corporate Veil Before Serving the Right Company

Foreign affiliates cannot be held liable by veil-piercing unless properly served first; labor tribunals must acquire jurisdiction before deciding corporate liability. Employees and claimants cannot shortcut jurisdiction by arguing that related corporations are really one and the same. Before a Philippine labor tribunal may pierce the corporate veil and impose solidary liability on a parent […]

Derivative Suits Can Be Dismissed When Stockholders Skip Appraisal Rights Allegations

Stockholders’ derivative suit over a corporate mortgage was dismissed for failing to plead appraisal rights and non-harassment requirements. Stockholders who sue in the corporation’s name cannot treat a derivative suit as a shortcut around corporate remedies. When the challenged corporate act involves the sale, mortgage, or disposition of substantially all corporate assets, the complaint must […]

Courts Can Freeze Rental Income While Ownership and Sharing Rights Are Still Being Tried

Courts may order disputed rental income deposited during litigation to preserve the fund without prejudging ownership or entitlement. A party receiving disputed rental income may be ordered to deposit the money in court before final judgment when the funds are regularly collected during the case and must be preserved for whoever is eventually declared entitled […]

When a Private Person Can Be Dropped from a Graft Case for Lack of Conspiracy

Private persons cannot be tried for graft without probable cause of conspiracy with public officers; tax and corporate records helped defeat the charge. A private individual cannot be forced to stand trial for graft merely because prosecutors suspect ownership, influence, or benefit from a questioned government transaction. When the charge is violation of Section 3(e) […]

When Corporate Control Is Disputed, Courts Cannot Use Injunctions to Decide the Boardroom War Early

A disputed corporate election cannot justify injunction without a clear legal right, especially where estate shares, voting authority, and quorum remain unresolved. A faction claiming control of a corporation cannot obtain a preliminary injunction merely by presenting a disputed election as presumptively valid. When the right to manage the company depends on contested voting rights, […]

Business Disputes, Cybercrime Cases, and Competition Claims Now Have More Designated Trial Courts Nationwide

More RTC branches were designated to hear commercial, cybercrime, and competition cases, improving venue access for Philippine business litigants. Companies, shareholders, creditors, intellectual property owners, and parties in cybercrime or competition disputes may now have more practical access to the proper trial court because additional Regional Trial Court branches were designated to hear specialized commercial, […]

Property Owners Can Enforce Ejectment Judgments Immediately After RTC Appeal

RTC ejectment judgments are immediately executory after appeal. Courts cannot delay enforcement by requiring discretionary “good reasons” for execution. Winning an unlawful detainer case on appeal before the Regional Trial Court gives the property owner an immediate enforcement remedy: the RTC judgment is immediately executory, and the court has no discretion to delay execution merely […]

Majority Stockholders Cannot Use Derivative Suits to Bypass the Board

Majority stockholders cannot use derivative suits to bypass board authority when a corporation can sue in its own name over corporate property. Majority stockholders who control a corporation cannot sue in a derivative capacity merely because a corporate asset was allegedly misused. If the corporation can act through its board, the proper plaintiff is the […]

Bouncing Checks, Corporate Officers, and the Notice Rule: When Personal Liability Survives a Corporate Signature

The Supreme Court held that B.P. 22 liability requires proof of notice of dishonor and that corporate officers may still face personal liability for bounced checks. Corporate officers who sign company checks cannot automatically escape personal exposure by invoking the corporation’s separate personality, especially when they personally undertook the obligation behind the checks. But a […]

Missed DOLE Appeals Can Lock In Personal Liability for Corporate Officers

A missed DOLE appeal made a compliance order final, reinstating a corporate officer’s solidary liability for wage awards despite corporate personality defenses. Employers and corporate officers who receive a DOLE compliance order must treat the appeal period as a hard deadline: filing the wrong pleading can make the order final, even if the officer later […]