A Wrong Caption Should Not Erase a Corporation’s Right to Recover Civil Liability

A corporation’s civil claim survives a wrong case caption when records show its interest and its officer’s authority in a B.P. 22-related dispute. A defective or changed case caption does not automatically defeat a corporation’s right to recover civil liability when the record clearly shows that the corporation was the real party affected and that […]

Hospital Doctors Are Not Employees Just Because a Board Appointed Them

A hospital pathologist appointed by board resolution was not a corporate officer or employee because CDMC lacked by-law proof and work control. Professionals who serve a company may fall outside both corporate-officer status and employee status when their position is not fixed in the by-laws and the company does not control how, when, and where […]

When a Corporate President’s Signature Can Bind the Company: Apparent Authority, Bank Loans, and Compromise Judgments

A corporation may be bound by its president’s settlement when its conduct created apparent authority and it delayed objecting for years. A company may still be bound by a president’s loan-related settlement even without a produced board resolution if the corporation previously held that officer out as authorized, accepted the benefits of the transaction, and […]

When the BOI Cannot Take Back a Tax Holiday Without Substantial Evidence

The Supreme Court held that BOI tax incentives cannot be withdrawn without a written legal basis and substantial evidence of noncompliance. Investment incentives cannot be withdrawn merely because an agency later disagrees with how a registered enterprise implemented its project. When the government grants an income tax holiday subject to conditions, the agency seeking to […]

When Ombudsman Exonerations Become Final: Why Complainants Cannot Always Appeal Dismissed Graft Complaints

Ombudsman exonerations in administrative cases are generally final and unappealable; grossly disadvantageous contracts require substantial proof. A complainant who reports alleged graft may trigger an Ombudsman investigation, but once the Ombudsman exonerates the public officers in an administrative case, the complainant generally cannot appeal simply because he disagrees with the dismissal. The ruling draws an […]

When Tax Data Becomes Public Evidence: Lawyers May Use SEC-Filed Financial Statements in Disputes

The Supreme Court held that lawyers may use publicly available SEC-filed audited financial statements in disputes without violating tax confidentiality rules. Corporate financial statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission are not treated like confidential income tax returns merely because they contain revenue, income, or tax-related figures. For businesses involved in procurement disputes, tax […]

Public SEC Financial Statements Are Not Confidential Tax Returns

Public SEC-filed financial statements are not confidential ITRs. The Court dismissed a lawyer misconduct complaint over use of audited financial records. A lawyer does not commit tax-related misconduct merely by using a corporation’s publicly available audited financial statements to support allegations in a pleading. For companies, this ruling draws an important boundary: not every financial […]

Asset Buyers Are Not Automatically Liable for a Seller’s Labor Judgment

A labor judgment cannot be enforced against non-parties added only at execution; corporate veil piercing requires jurisdiction and clear proof of wrongdoing. A winning employee cannot collect a final labor judgment from a company’s president or from a related asset buyer by simply adding them at the execution stage. The Supreme Court drew a hard […]

Security Guards Cannot Be Forced to Drop Labor Claims Before Getting Reassigned

Security agencies may reassign guards, but not to force withdrawal of labor claims. The Court upheld illegal dismissal while absolving the president absent bad faith. Security agencies may transfer or place guards on floating status for legitimate business reasons, but they cross the line into illegal dismissal when reassignment is used as leverage to force […]

A Missed Hearing Can Cost You the Case: When Courts May Treat Silence as Waiver

A missed hearing may waive cross-examination and evidence rights. Dy Teban clarifies due process, postponements, certiorari, and commercial court jurisdiction. A party who repeatedly delays trial cannot later claim denial of due process when the court proceeds without him. The decisive lesson of Dy Teban is practical and unforgiving: the right to cross-examine witnesses and […]