Shareholder Lawsuits Over Unfinished Corporate Projects Must Go to the Right Commercial Court

Shareholder derivative suits over corporate projects must be filed in special commercial courts and must strictly plead exhaustion and other requisites. A shareholder who sues on behalf of a corporation cannot avoid the special rules for derivative suits by labeling the case as one for specific performance. When the complaint seeks to enforce a corporate […]

Receivership Is Not a Shortcut in Corporate Control Disputes: Courts Need Evidence Before Taking Over a Company

Receivership requires proof of imminent asset loss and business paralysis; suspicion of fraud and failed settlement are not enough to displace corporate management. A corporate dissenter cannot force a court-supervised takeover of a school, family corporation, or closely held company merely by alleging fraud, missing funds, or internal mismanagement. The party asking for a receiver […]

When a Special Commercial Court Can Still Hear an Ordinary Injunction Case

A Special Commercial Court remains an RTC with jurisdiction over ordinary injunction cases, including condominium property disputes not involving intra-corporate rights. A case should not be dismissed merely because it was assigned to a Regional Trial Court branch designated as a Special Commercial Court. If the complaint is an ordinary civil action for injunction and […]

When a Court Has Already Decided Corporate Membership, a Board Cannot Relitigate It by Passing a New Resolution

A final ruling on corporate membership bars relitigation; a later board resolution cannot revive issues already decided between the same parties. A corporation cannot defeat a final court ruling on membership rights by issuing a new board resolution that merely repeats the same rejected position. Once a court has necessarily decided that a person remains […]

When a Corporate Control Dispute Can Stop a Criminal Case

A corporate faction cannot rush criminal charges while its authority to act for the company is still under litigation. The criminal case may be suspended. A criminal complaint filed in the corporationโ€™s name may be suspended when the authority of the supposed corporate officers is still being litigated in a separate intra-corporate case. For business […]

Courts Cannot Hand Corporate Control to an Outsider by Injunction

Corporate control belongs to the board, not an outside intervenor. The Supreme Court stopped an injunction that handed management to a private claimant. Corporate control cannot be transferred by a trial court to a private outsider merely because that outsider has a contract with someone claiming authority over the corporation. Management of a stock corporation […]

When Corporate Disputes Belong in the RTC, Not the Sandiganbayan

PCGG involvement does not automatically place a corporate dispute in Sandiganbayan; intra-corporate controversies belong before designated RTC courts. A corporation challenging a government-held shareholder interest cannot automatically go to the Sandiganbayan simply because the Presidential Commission on Good Government is involved. When the dispute concerns shareholder rights, board conflicts, capital stock, or stock exchange listing […]

When a Corporate Dispute Can Stop an Estafa Case Over Company Collections

Corporate authority disputes can suspend estafa cases when the validity of demand and alleged misappropriation depend on who may act for the corporation. A criminal estafa case over company money may be suspended when the accusedโ€™s alleged duty to turn over funds depends on a still-unresolved corporate authority dispute. For business owners, family corporations, property […]

Tax Refunds Cannot Be Denied Just Because One BIR Form Is Missing

The Supreme Court allowed PNBโ€™s tax refund, ruling that non-use of creditable withholding tax may be proven without BIR Form 2307. Taxpayers claiming a refund of excess creditable withholding tax may prove non-use through competent evidence other than BIR Form No. 2307. The ruling matters because it prevents refund claims from being defeated by a […]

Stockholders Can Enforce Corporate Inspection Rights in the RTC Even When Sequestered Companies Are Involved

Stockholders may enforce inspection rights in the RTC when the dispute is intra-corporate, even if the company has sequestration history. Stockholders and corporate representatives do not lose the ordinary remedy of enforcing inspection rights merely because a corporation has a sequestration history or a factional board dispute. When the controversy is about corporate books, board […]