When a Firing Is Too Harsh: Minor Workplace Mistakes Cannot Automatically Cost an Employee Their Job

Dismissal must be proportionate to the offense; minor lapses may not justify termination, while corporate officer disputes belong outside the NLRC. Employers may discipline employees for mistakes, absence, delay, or failure to follow instructions, but dismissal remains a last-resort penalty: the misconduct must be serious, willful, work-related, and proportionate to the punishment imposed. Why This […]

Void Execution Sales Cannot Defeat the True Owner’s Right to Get the Property Back

The Supreme Court ruled that property sold through a void execution sale must be restored when actual restitution remains legally and physically possible. Property taken through a void execution sale must be returned to its true owner when actual restitution is still physically and legally possible. A judgment creditor who later sells the property to […]

When a President Is a Corporate Officer, the NLRC Cannot Award Illegal Dismissal Damages

Corporate officers named in by-laws cannot pursue removal disputes as ordinary NLRC illegal dismissal cases; the proper forum is the regular court. Corporate presidents and other officers named in a corporation’s by-laws cannot automatically treat their removal as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the NLRC. If the dispute concerns the election, appointment, term, or […]

Mining Contract Disputes Must Go to Arbitration When Parties Agreed to Arbitrate

The Supreme Court dismissed parallel mining contract cases for forum shopping and enforced arbitration despite attempts to proceed in court. Businesses that agree to arbitrate cannot avoid that bargain by filing parallel cases before courts and administrative agencies, especially when both cases arise from the same contract, seek substantially the same relief, and risk conflicting […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Be Made Personally Liable by Execution Alone

Corporate officers cannot be made personally liable for labor judgments by execution alone without summons, due process, and proof of bad faith. Business owners and corporate officers cannot be made personally liable for a corporation’s labor judgment simply because the company cannot pay. A final award against a corporation does not automatically become a personal […]

Security Guards Left Without New Assignments May Be Illegally Dismissed, Not Treated as Having Abandoned Work

Security guards relieved from posts without new assignments may be illegally dismissed, but corporate officers are not personally liable absent bad faith. Security guards and other project- or client-assigned workers are not deemed to have abandoned their jobs merely because their last post was withdrawn. When an employer relieves workers from an assignment but fails […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Personally Liable for Company Labor Debts

Corporate officers are not personally liable for company labor debts unless bad faith is alleged, proven, and adjudged before execution. Business owners and corporate officers are not automatically required to pay a corporation’s labor judgment from their personal assets merely because the company has closed or cannot satisfy the award. Personal liability requires more than […]

When a Contractor Is Just a Corporate Mask: Employees May Sue the Principal Employer for Illegal Dismissal

A principal company may be treated as the real employer when a contractor is merely a labor-only conduit, but officers need proof of bad faith for personal liability. Employees assigned through a contractor may still claim illegal dismissal directly against the principal company when the contractor is undercapitalized, unregistered, dependent on the principal, and used […]

When Final Judgment Can Still Yield to Substantial Justice in Family Corporation Share Disputes

A withdrawn appeal over family corporation shares may be reinstated when failed reconciliation and serious ownership claims make strict finality unjust. A party who withdrew an appeal because he was led to expect family reconciliation may still be allowed to revive that appeal when the expected settlement never materializes and strict finality would produce a […]