VAT Refunds for Zero-Rated Sales: Court Allows Partial Recovery Despite BIR Denial

The tax court allowed only P13.198 million of a VAT refund claim after disallowing unsupported zero-rated sales, incomplete receipts, and invalid input VAT. VAT-registered businesses claiming refunds on zero-rated sales must do more than show that their customers are PEZA entities or foreign clients. They must prove each sale and each input tax with compliant […]

Missed Electronic Filing Rules Can End a Tax Certiorari Case Before It Begins

A tax certiorari petition was dismissed after the petitioner failed to submit the required soft copy within 24 hours of hard-copy filing. Taxpayers and individuals challenging tax-related criminal proceedings before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat electronic filing requirements as jurisdictionally serious compliance obligations because a petition may be deemed not filed, and the […]

Late Motions Can End Tax Collection Challenges Before the Merits Are Heard

A taxpayer’s CTA challenge to BIR levy measures failed after its motion for reconsideration was filed six days late, making the dismissal final. Taxpayers challenging BIR collection measures must treat Court of Tax Appeals deadlines as jurisdictional, because even a potentially serious objection to a levy, warrant, or collection action may be lost if a […]

Tax Appeals Can Be Lost on Filing Deadlines Even Before the Merits Are Heard

A tax assessment appeal was dismissed after the taxpayer failed to overcome receipt and filing deadline issues before the Court of Tax Appeals. Taxpayers challenging a BIR final decision must treat the appeal period as a jurisdictional deadline, not a procedural formality. If the Court of Tax Appeals finds that the petition for review was […]

Invalid BIR Audit Authority Can Cancel Deficiency Tax Assessments

A taxpayer defeated a P3.448M income tax and EWT assessment after the court found invalid audit authority and denial of assessment due process. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax and withholding tax assessments should examine not only the BIR computation, but also the authority of the revenue officers and the fairness of the assessment process. In […]

Tax Refund Claim Denied After Taxpayer Tried to Reopen Evidence on Alleged Double FWT Payment

The CTA denied reconsideration and refused to reopen a final withholding tax refund case because the taxpayer’s added proof was forgotten, not newly discovered, evidence. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit for allegedly overpaid withholding taxes must prove the overpayment with complete, competent, and timely presented evidence during trial; they cannot wait for an […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided for Premature FANs, But Refunds Still Require a Proper Claim

A premature FAN can void a BIR assessment, but taxpayers must still file a proper refund or tax credit claim to recover amounts already paid. Taxpayers who receive a Formal Assessment Notice before the 15-day period to answer a Preliminary Assessment Notice expires may have a strong due process defense against the assessment, but any […]

Input VAT Claims Fail Without Complete Invoices and Court Evidence

A VAT taxpayer failed to prove input tax claims before the CTA; the compromise penalty was cancelled, but P74.75M in deficiency VAT and interest was upheld. Taxpayers facing deficiency VAT assessments cannot rely on explanations, reconciliations, or documents allegedly submitted during audit unless they can prove their claims with competent evidence before the Court of […]

BIR Cannot Reopen a Settled Audit Through a New LOA for the Same Taxable Period

A taxpayer defeated a P41.3M BIR assessment after the tax court voided a repeated audit, unauthorized officer action, prescription, and defective demand. Taxpayers who have already gone through a completed BIR audit, received final decisions, and paid the assessed amounts may challenge a later attempt to revive the same issue through another Letter of Authority, […]

Taxpayers Can Defend CWT Refund Wins When Reconsideration Merely Rehashes Old Arguments

Taxpayer’s β‚±10.52M excess CWT refund survives reconsideration after the Commissioner merely repeated arguments already rejected by the tax court. Companies pursuing refunds or tax credits for excess creditable withholding taxes gain an important litigation reminder: once the taxpayer has proven entitlement and the Commissioner merely repeats arguments already rejected, a refund victory can survive even […]