A premature FAN can void a BIR assessment, but taxpayers must still file a proper refund or tax credit claim to recover amounts already paid.

Taxpayers who receive a Formal Assessment Notice before the 15-day period to answer a Preliminary Assessment Notice expires may have a strong due process defense against the assessment, but any recovery of amounts already paid still requires a properly filed refund or tax credit claim. The decision is a reminder that defeating a deficiency tax assessment and recovering prior payments are related, but procedurally different, remedies.

Background of the Tax Assessment Dispute

The taxpayer was engaged in freight and cargo consolidation and forwarding. For taxable year 2009, the BIR issued a Letter of Authority authorizing the examination of the taxpayer’s books of accounts and accounting records. The audit later resulted in a Preliminary Assessment Notice covering alleged deficiency income tax, value-added tax, expanded withholding tax, final withholding tax, fringe benefits tax, improperly accumulated earnings tax, and documentary stamp tax.

The dispute reached the Court of Tax Appeals after the BIR pursued substantial deficiency tax assessments against the taxpayer. In the background of the appeal, the case was docketed as CTA EB No. 3024. The taxpayer argued that the assessment process was defective because it received the Preliminary Assessment Notice only on January 4, 2013, but the Formal Assessment Notice was issued on January 14, 2013, before the taxpayer’s 15-day period to respond had expired.

The taxpayer also made payments during the administrative stage. These included amounts for income tax, VAT, expanded withholding tax, and fringe benefits tax. The BIR later acknowledged the VAT payment as valid and cancelled the VAT deficiency assessment at the administrative level, but it continued to pursue the remaining assessments. The Court in Division voided the assessment documents and ordered the return or issuance of tax credit certificates for the amounts previously paid. The Commissioner elevated the case to the En Banc.

Premature Issuance of the FAN Violated Taxpayer Due Process

The En Banc sustained the finding that the assessments were void because the BIR did not observe the taxpayer’s statutory right to respond to the Preliminary Assessment Notice. Under the applicable assessment rules, a taxpayer is given 15 days from receipt of the PAN to file a reply. Only after the taxpayer responds, or after the period lapses without a response, may the BIR proceed to issue the Final Letter of Demand or Formal Assessment Notice.

The court rejected the argument that due process was satisfied simply because the taxpayer was later able to file a protest, request reconsideration, and appeal. The defect occurred at the preliminary assessment stage. By issuing the FAN before the taxpayer’s period to reply had expired, the BIR effectively deprived the taxpayer of a meaningful opportunity to contest the preliminary findings before a formal assessment was made.

This is important for corporate taxpayers because the PAN is not a ceremonial document. It is part of the statutory due process framework for tax assessments. A premature FAN suggests that the BIR either pre-decided the case or failed to wait for, receive, and consider the taxpayer’s response before escalating the matter into a formal assessment. The En Banc therefore affirmed that the Formal Assessment Notice, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, and the Commissioner’s later decision for taxable year 2009 were void.

A Void Assessment Does Not Automatically Produce a Refund

The taxpayer won on the validity of the assessment, but not on the refund issue. The En Banc modified the Court in Division’s decision by deleting the orders requiring the Commissioner to return or issue tax credit certificates for the amounts previously paid.

For the VAT payment, the court held that there was no longer a disputed VAT assessment for the CTA to review because the Commissioner had already acknowledged the VAT payment as full payment and cancelled the VAT deficiency at the administrative level. Since VAT was no longer part of the disputed assessment elevated to the CTA, the court found no basis to order a refund or tax credit certificate in that assessment appeal.

For the amounts paid as income tax, expanded withholding tax, and fringe benefits tax, the court emphasized the separate statutory requirements for refund claims. Sections 204(C) and 229 of the National Internal Revenue Code require a taxpayer seeking recovery of erroneously or illegally collected internal revenue taxes to file a written administrative claim with the Commissioner within two years from payment. A judicial claim must likewise comply with the statutory period.

The taxpayer’s petition before the Court in Division was treated as an appeal questioning the validity of the deficiency assessments, not as a refund suit. The records showed that the taxpayer did not file a written administrative claim for refund or tax credit with the Commissioner, and did not specifically plead or pray for refund in the petition or subsequent pleadings. For that reason, the En Banc held that the CTA could not award a refund or tax credit certificate even though the underlying assessment was void.

Why This Matters for Taxpayers Facing BIR Deficiency Assessments

The decision draws a sharp line between assessment cancellation and tax recovery. A taxpayer may successfully argue that an assessment is void because of due process violations, such as the premature issuance of a FAN. However, if the taxpayer has already paid some amount during the audit, reinvestigation, or settlement discussions, the taxpayer should not assume that the CTA will automatically order the amount returned.

For CFOs, tax managers, and corporate counsel, the practical lesson is to preserve both remedies. If the taxpayer’s objective is only to cancel the remaining assessment, the protest and CTA appeal must focus on the invalidity of the assessment. But if the taxpayer also wants to recover amounts already paid, the taxpayer should separately evaluate whether to file a written administrative refund or tax credit claim within the two-year period, and whether the judicial pleading must expressly include refund allegations and a refund prayer.

This ruling is especially relevant in BIR audits where taxpayers make partial payments based on revised computations, settlement discussions, or draft payment forms. Such payments may later become contested if the BIR refuses to treat them as full settlement. Once that happens, taxpayers should immediately assess the refund timetable. Waiting until the assessment case is decided may be too late if the statutory refund requirements were never complied with.

Key Takeaways for BIR Audit and CTA Litigation Strategy

First, taxpayers should carefully document the actual date of receipt of the Preliminary Assessment Notice. In this case, the taxpayer’s receipt date was critical because it showed that the FAN was issued before the 15-day reply period expired. Receipt dates, registry records, stamped copies, and internal routing logs can decide whether a due process defense is available.

Second, a protest to the FAN does not necessarily cure the BIR’s failure to observe due process at the PAN stage. The right to respond to the PAN exists before the formal assessment is issued. The later ability to protest a formal assessment is not a substitute for the earlier right to be heard.

Third, taxpayers must plead the correct remedy. A petition that asks the CTA to cancel an assessment is not automatically a refund case. If amounts have already been paid and the taxpayer wants them returned, the pleadings and prior administrative filings must be aligned with the refund provisions of the Tax Code.

Finally, payment during an audit should be treated with caution. Before paying any alleged deficiency tax, taxpayers should clarify whether the payment is a settlement, partial payment, undisputed payment, or payment under protest, and should assess how the payment affects protest rights, refund deadlines, and future litigation strategy.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in BIR audits, deficiency tax assessments, administrative protests, refund claims, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice helps clients identify due process defects, preserve appeal periods, prepare protest submissions, evaluate refund exposure, and structure pleadings to protect both assessment cancellation and tax recovery remedies.

For businesses facing a BIR assessment, a premature FAN, a disputed FDDA, or uncertainty over whether prior payments may still be recovered, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax assessment defense and CTA litigation strategy.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *