False Travel Liquidations Can Become Criminal Cases, Even When the Amount Is Small

False travel liquidation documents can support falsification and graft convictions even for small per diem overpayments, though clemency may be recommended. Government personnel who liquidate official travel expenses must tell the truth about actual travel dates, not merely repeat the dates written in a travel order. A false itinerary or certificate of travel completed may […]

When an Unlisted Witness Cannot Save the Prosecution’s Case

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused after excluding an unlisted substitute eyewitness, stressing that pre-trial orders bind criminal trials. Criminal defendants can now rely more firmly on a practical trial safeguard: if the prosecution fails to list a witness during pre-trial, that witness may be excluded unless the State gives a specific, legally sufficient reason […]

Drug Case Plea Bargaining Cannot Be Denied Just Because Two Charges Came From One Arrest

The Supreme Court held that two drug charges from one arrest do not automatically disqualify an accused from plea bargaining under the drug case framework. Accused persons in drug cases may not be denied plea bargaining simply because they face both sale and possession charges from the same police operation, when the Supreme Court’s own […]

DOJ Prosecutors May Use a Higher Screening Standard Before Filing Criminal Cases

The Supreme Court upheld the DOJ’s 2024 preliminary investigation rules, allowing prosecutors to require prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction. People facing criminal complaints before prosecutors may now invoke a more demanding screening standard at the preliminary investigation stage: the DOJ’s 2024 rules requiring prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction remain […]

Judicial Errors Are Not Misconduct: When a Losing Party Cannot Turn a Court Ruling Into an Administrative Case

The Supreme Court held that alleged judicial errors cannot support discipline without proof of bad faith, dishonesty, corruption, or gross ignorance. A party who believes a judge made a wrong ruling must generally use the proper judicial remedy, not an administrative complaint, unless the alleged error is shown to be tainted by fraud, dishonesty, corruption, […]

Carrying a Knife During Election Season Is Not Automatically an Election Offense

The Supreme Court acquitted a man found with a knife during election season because prosecutors failed to prove he was within 100 meters of a polling place. A person found with a knife during the election period cannot be convicted under the Omnibus Election Code unless the prosecution proves the weapon was carried in or […]

Private Complainants Can Challenge Acquittals Only Through the State β€” and Even Then, Double Jeopardy Sets a High Wall

Private complainants may challenge the criminal aspect with prosecutor conformity, but acquittals after demurrer stand absent grave abuse or denial of due process. A private complainant who loses a criminal case after a demurrer to evidence cannot simply relitigate the acquittal by arguing that the trial court weighed the evidence incorrectly. The practical rule is […]

Self-Defense Fails When the Force Used Turns a Workplace Confrontation Into a Killing

The Supreme Court rejected self-defense but reduced murder to homicide after treachery was not proven in a fatal superior-subordinate shooting. A person who claims self-defense after a fatal confrontation must prove more than fear, anger, or a prior scuffle: unlawful aggression must be clearly shown, and the response must be reasonably necessary. Where an accused […]

Flight and Bloodstains Are Not Enough: Reasonable Doubt in Circumstantial Evidence Cases

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused in a robbery with homicide case, holding that flight and unproven bloodstains cannot replace proof beyond reasonable doubt. A person cannot be convicted on suspicion, proximity, fear-driven flight, or bloodstained items found in a shared space unless the prosecution proves an unbroken chain of circumstances pointing to guilt beyond […]