When Tax Officials Challenge a Conviction, Procedural Rules Cannot Be Invented Against Them

Supreme Court held that Sandiganbayan could not reject a tax reassessment conviction appeal motion for lacking a hearing date under the wrong rule. Public officers convicted over local tax reassessment actions may still obtain appellate review when their motion for reconsideration was rejected under a procedural requirement that the Sandiganbayan rules did not actually impose. […]

When Corporate Fraud Allegations Can Lead to Arrest Before Trial

Probable cause, not proof beyond reasonable doubt, is enough for a warrant of arrest in corporate fraud and syndicated estafa cases. A person accused in an investment or corporate fraud case cannot defeat a warrant of arrest by demanding that the judge first conduct a mini-trial on guilt. If the prosecution records show facts that […]

GOCC Managers Cannot Avoid Sandiganbayan Cases by Pointing to Salary Grade

GOCC managers may face Sandiganbayan trial despite Salary Grade 26 when their position is expressly covered and the alleged graft relates to office. Managers and directors of government-owned or controlled corporations may fall within the Sandiganbayan’s jurisdiction even if their salary grade is below Grade 27. The practical lesson is direct: for anti-graft cases involving […]

When a Corporate Officer Faces a Criminal Case, the Victim Can Still Pursue Civil Damages Inside the Same Trial

The Supreme Court allowed private prosecutors to intervene in a corporate falsification case because civil liability was deemed included in the criminal action. A person harmed by alleged corporate falsification may pursue the civil consequences of the crime within the criminal case itself, unless that civil action was waived, reserved, or already filed separately. The […]

Photocopies Can Prove Corporate Misappropriation When the Originals Are Lost

Lost originals do not automatically defeat a case. The Supreme Court allowed photocopies after proof of loss, authenticity, and admissions by the accused. Corporate officers accused of keeping company funds cannot defeat a criminal case simply by objecting that the prosecution has only photocopies, if the originals were lost without bad faith and the prosecution […]

Judges Must Hold a Bail Hearing Before Releasing an Accused in a Capital Case

Courts must hold a bail hearing before releasing an accused in a capital case; skipping that process may amount to gross ignorance of the law. A judge handling a capital offense cannot release an accused on bail by shortcut, assumption, or personal assessment alone. Before bail may be granted where the charge is punishable by […]

A Criminal Information Must Allege the Facts That Make the Penalty Heavier

Credible child testimony sustained a rape conviction, but the penalty was reduced because the information failed to allege the qualifying facts for death. An accused person may be convicted on the credible testimony of a rape victim alone, but cannot be punished with a higher penalty unless the facts that increase the penalty were clearly […]

A Rape Conviction May Stand Even When the Higher Penalty Fails

A rape conviction may stand despite an imperfect information, but the higher penalty fails when the qualifying relationship was not specifically charged. A criminal conviction can survive a defect in the charge, but the punishment cannot exceed what the accused was properly informed he had to defend against. In rape prosecutions, this means that an […]

Small Inconsistencies Do Not Destroy a Rape Conviction When the Core Testimony Remains Credible

Credible victim testimony can sustain a rape conviction despite minor inconsistencies, but penalty-increasing facts must be properly alleged in the information. Minor inconsistencies in a rape victim’s narration will not automatically defeat a criminal case when the essential story remains clear: that force, intimidation, and sexual assault occurred. For accused persons, complainants, and families involved […]