When a Judge Acts on the Wrong Case, Good Intentions Are Not Enough

Judges may not decide cases outside their sala, even for good reasons. The Court fined two RTC judges for taking over vacant MTCC cases. Judges cannot decide, dismiss, or otherwise act on cases that are not pending before their own sala, even when they believe they are protecting an accused person’s liberty. The Supreme Court […]

LPG Refillers Can Face Criminal Charges for Using Branded Cylinders Without Written Authority

Unauthorized refilling of branded LPG cylinders may support BP 33 charges, but only officers managing the business or responsible employees may face liability. LPG refillers cannot treat a customer’s possession of a branded cylinder as permission to refill it. When a cylinder bears another company’s brand, embossing, or identifying mark, refilling it without written authority […]

Tax Evasion Begins When the False Return Is Filed: Why Later Payments May Not Stop Prosecution

Tax evasion may be prosecuted once a fraudulent return is filed; later payments, VAP claims, or audit immunity may not bar criminal charges. A taxpayer accused of filing fraudulent returns cannot automatically avoid criminal prosecution by pointing to later tax payments, audit immunity certificates, or settlement programs. The Supreme Court held that tax evasion is […]

Perjury Requires More Than a Contradiction in Sworn Corporate Filings

Perjury requires proof of deliberate factual falsehood, not just contradiction or a disputed legal conclusion in sworn corporate or tax-related filings. A sworn allegation in a corporate or tax-related filing does not become perjury merely because another signed document appears to contradict it. To convict a person for perjury, prosecutors must prove not only that […]

A Criminal Case Cannot Be Thrown Out Before the Prosecution Presents Its Evidence

The Court held that weak evidence cannot justify dismissal before trial; a motion to quash tests the charge, not the prosecution’s proof. Criminal defendants may challenge a defective charge early, but they cannot convert a motion to quash into a premature trial on the evidence. In People v. Dumlao, the Court drew a firm line […]

When a Civil Case Will Not Stop a Criminal Case for Falsification

A civil loan dispute did not suspend falsification charges because it would not necessarily determine the accused officer’s guilt or innocence. A pending civil dispute will not automatically suspend a criminal prosecution for falsification. A person accused of making documents appear to show a loan, transaction, or participation that allegedly did not exist must face […]

Local Water District Officials Can Face Graft Charges as Public Officers

Local water district officials are public officers who may face graft charges because water districts are GOCCs created by special law, not private corporations. Managers and officers of local water districts cannot avoid anti-graft prosecution by arguing that their districts are private corporations. Because local water districts are government-owned or controlled corporations created by special […]

Tax Fraud Complaints Need Evidence, Not Suspicion: When Ombudsman Dismissals Stand

Ombudsman dismissals stand absent grave abuse. Tax fraud and graft complaints need evidence of probable cause, not suspicion or disagreement. Tax fraud and graft accusations do not move forward merely because a complainant believes that an official acted unfairly, exercised discretion poorly, or allowed a suspect to travel. The controlling lesson is practical and important: […]