When Victim Testimony Is Enough: The Credibility Rule That Can Sustain a Rape Conviction

Credible victim testimony, prompt reporting, and medical findings can sustain a rape conviction even without laboratory proof of drugging or eyewitnesses. A rape conviction may stand even without laboratory proof that the victim was drugged when the complainant gives credible, consistent testimony, immediately reports the assault, and medical findings corroborate sexual violation. For accused persons, […]

When a Victim Recants After Conviction: Why Later Affidavits Usually Cannot Erase Trial Testimony

A later affidavit of desistance did not erase credible trial testimony, but the penalty was reduced because nighttime was not alleged in the information. A later affidavit of desistance does not automatically undo a conviction when the trial court has already heard the victim testify, observed her demeanor, and found her account credible. For accused […]

When Rape Penalties Fail on Technical Pleading: Why Prosecutors Must Allege Every Qualifying Circumstance

Rape conviction affirmed, but penalty reduced because qualifying relationship was not specifically alleged and proven beyond reasonable doubt. A rape conviction may stand even when the victimโ€™s medical findings are disputed, but the harshest penalty cannot be imposed unless every aggravating or qualifying circumstance was both clearly alleged in the charge and proven beyond reasonable […]

Rape Convictions Involving Mental Incapacity Require Proof, Not Assumptions

Mental incapacity in rape cases must be proven beyond reasonable doubt. The Court acquitted where disability and force were not sufficiently established. When a rape charge depends on the claim that the complainant could not validly consent because of mental incapacity, the prosecution must prove that incapacity with the same rigor required for every element […]

A Defective Criminal Complaint Can Void a Conviction, Even After a Guilty Plea

A conviction may be void when the complaint fails to allege the essential elements of the crime, even after a guilty plea in a serious criminal case. A criminal conviction cannot stand when the complaint or information fails to allege the essential facts constituting the offense charged. Even a guilty plea, even a serious accusation […]

A Conviction Cannot Stand on Recycled Testimony: Why Witnesses Must Testify in Open Court

The Supreme Court vacated a conviction after witnesses merely adopted prior testimony, reaffirming the accusedโ€™s right to live testimony and cross-examination. An accused person cannot be convicted through a shortcut that merely adopts testimony given in another trial. When a witness is available, the prosecution must present that witness in open court so the accused […]

Rape Convictions Can Stand on Credible Testimony Despite Minor Inconsistencies

Rape conviction affirmed despite minor inconsistencies; credible victim testimony and corroborating medical evidence proved guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A rape conviction may be affirmed even when a child witness cannot recall every detail, so long as the testimony on the central act is credible, consistent with the medical findings, and sufficient to prove guilt beyond […]

When Age Is Not Proven, a Rape Conviction May Stand but the Death Penalty Falls

A rape conviction may stand on credible testimony, but qualified rape penalties require independent proof of age and other qualifying facts. A rape conviction may rest on the credible testimony of the victim, but the prosecution cannot impose the heavier penalty for qualified rape unless it independently proves every qualifying circumstance, including the victimโ€™s age. […]

Eyewitness Mistakes Do Not Automatically Create Reasonable Doubt

Eyewitness inconsistencies did not defeat conviction, but lack of proof of treachery and premeditation reduced multiple murder to homicide. Criminal convictions do not collapse merely because frightened eyewitnesses made imperfect identifications, but prosecutors still must prove the exact legal character of the crime charged. In People v. Recepcion, the Court treated the witnessesโ€™ confusion as […]

Death Penalty Cannot Stand When the Information Fails to Allege the Qualifying Circumstance

A rape conviction was affirmed, but the death penalty was barred because the qualifying father-daughter relationship was not alleged in the information. An accused may be convicted on the strength of a victimโ€™s credible testimony, but a court cannot impose the death penalty unless the facts that legally qualify the offense for death are specifically […]