When a Child’s Testimony Convicts but Age Proof Controls the Penalty in Rape Cases

A child’s credible testimony sustained rape convictions, but the death penalty was reduced because the prosecution failed to independently prove the victim’s age. A rape conviction may rest on the credible, straightforward testimony of the victim, especially where the accused is a family member with moral ascendancy, but a harsher penalty cannot be imposed unless […]

Police-Assisted Counsel Can Still Make a Confession Admissible When the Accused Knowingly Accepts the Lawyer

Police-assisted counsel does not automatically void a confession. The Court affirmed rape convictions after finding valid counsel, voluntary statements, conspiracy, and failed alibi. A custodial confession is not automatically thrown out just because the lawyer was called in by the police. What matters is whether the accused was informed of the right to counsel, understood […]

Selling Government Property Too Cheap Can Become an Anti-Graft Case

Government asset sales at suspiciously low prices can trigger anti-graft liability when public officers intervene and the transaction disadvantages the government. Public officers who dispose of government property at an unreasonably low price, without proper authority, bidding, valuation, and documentation, may face criminal liability even if the transaction is presented as an ordinary sale of […]

When a Child Victim Cannot Remember Every Date, a Rape Conviction Can Still Stand

A child rape conviction may stand despite imperfect recall of exact dates when credible testimony proves the acts and identifies the accused beyond reasonable doubt. A rape conviction may stand even when a child victim cannot recall every exact date of abuse, as long as the acts charged are proven with credible, consistent testimony and […]

Judges Cannot Grant Bail on Recognizance Before the Accused Is in Custody

Courts cannot grant bail or recognizance before custody attaches; judges who ignore this basic rule may be disciplined for gross ignorance of the law. A person who has not yet been arrested or voluntarily surrendered cannot be released on bail or recognizance, because there is no custody from which the court can release him. For […]

When Bail Is Discretionary, Judges Must Still Hold the Hearing That Protects Both Sides

Judges must hold a real bail hearing in capital cases before granting bail; skipping the evidentiary process can result in discipline. A person charged with a capital offense does not automatically lose the right to seek bail, but the judge cannot grant bail on instinct, sympathy, or shortcut procedure. When bail is discretionary, the court […]

Judges Cannot Skip Basic Criminal Procedure Even in Heinous Crimes

A judge was fined for allowing defense evidence after a demurrer filed without leave was denied, confirming that basic criminal procedure binds courts. Judges who bypass basic criminal procedure may be disciplined even when the accused faces a grave or heinous charge. In this ruling, the Court made clear that the seriousness of a criminal […]

When a Judge May Refuse to Issue an Arrest Warrant Despite a Prosecutor’s Finding of Probable Cause

A prosecutor’s probable cause finding does not automatically require arrest; judges must independently decide whether a warrant is justified. A prosecutor’s finding of probable cause does not automatically send an accused person to jail. Before an arrest warrant may issue, the judge must make a separate judicial determination that probable cause exists for arrest and […]

When a Judge Has Family Ties to a Criminal Complainant, Inhibition Is Not Optional

Judges with disqualifying family ties must inhibit even during preliminary investigation when probable cause, warrants, and bail may affect liberty. A judge who is related to a party or interested complainant cannot cure the conflict by saying he was only conducting a preliminary investigation. When the judge must determine probable cause, issue a warrant, recommend […]

Judges Who Delay Simple Cases Can Be Fined Even When the Decision Is Eventually Issued

Court fined a judge for delayed judgment in a summary criminal case, while holding that failure to object waived the private prosecutor issue. Litigants in small criminal cases are entitled to more than a correct final judgment; they are entitled to a timely one. In Enriquez v. Judge Vallarta, the Court disciplined a trial judge […]