When Judicial Delay Becomes Misconduct but Not Always Punishment

A judge was found negligent for a seven-year delay in a murder complaint, but the case was dismissed after retirement, record recovery, and no bad faith. Judges who allow criminal complaints to stagnate may breach their judicial duties, but administrative discipline does not automatically follow when the judge has already retired, the missing records have […]

Penalty Hikes Cannot Reach Back: Why Older Fraud Cases Stay Under the Law in Force When the Act Was Done

Penalty increases cannot be applied retroactively to older fraud cases; jurisdiction depends on the penalty in force when the alleged act occurred. Criminal penalty increases do not automatically make older conduct more serious in court. When an alleged fraud or bouncing-check offense was committed before a harsher penalty law took effect, prosecutors and judges must […]

When the Government Misses Its Appeal Deadline, Certiorari Cannot Rescue the Case

Certiorari cannot replace a missed appeal from an order granting new trial, a rule vital in criminal, tax, and regulatory enforcement litigation. Procedural finality can decide a criminal case before the court ever reaches the merits. When an order granting a new trial is appealable, the losing party must appeal on time; it cannot wait, […]

When a Judge Makes a Procedural Mistake: Why Not Every Court Error Becomes Misconduct

A judgeโ€™s procedural lapses may draw warning but not discipline absent proof of bad faith, bias, or misconduct. The complaint against Judge Carmona was dismissed. A judgeโ€™s questionable handling of a criminal hearing does not automatically amount to administrative misconduct; what matters is whether the record shows bad faith, corruption, gross ignorance, or a breach […]

When a Judgeโ€™s Leniency Is Not Misconduct: The Good-Faith Adjudication Rule

Judges are not disciplined merely for lenient rulings when the record supports their action and no rule violation, irregularity, or bias is shown. A losing or disappointed litigant cannot turn every unfavorable courtroom decision into an administrative case against the judge. The doctrine from Tolentino v. Judge Tiong is a practical one: judicial discipline requires […]

Judges Cannot Shortcut Probable Cause by Accepting Bail

Judges must determine probable cause through proper preliminary examination; accepting bail does not replace the legal duty to screen criminal complaints. A person accused of a crime should not be forced to post bail, hire counsel, or suffer the stigma of prosecution until a judge has first made a lawful probable-cause determination through the preliminary […]

An Acquittal Cannot Be Repackaged as Certiorari: Why the State Usually Gets No Second Chance After a Criminal Dismissal

A merits-based acquittal cannot be revived through certiorari when review would place the accused in double jeopardy, even if the trial court may have erred. A criminal case that has already ended in an acquittal generally cannot be revived by calling the governmentโ€™s challenge a petition for certiorari. When a trial court dismisses a charge […]

When a Criminal Case Is Dismissed for Non-Appearance, the Judge Is Not Automatically Liable

Repeated non-appearance may justify dismissal for failure to prosecute when the judge gives fair warning and protects the accusedโ€™s speedy trial rights. A party who repeatedly fails to proceed with a criminal case cannot convert an unfavorable dismissal into an administrative case against the judge, especially where the court gave the parties several chances, warned […]

Habeas Corpus During Martial Law: When the Detainee, Not the Petitioner, Controls the Case

Habeas corpus remained available during martial law, but the Court allowed withdrawal when the detainee personally disavowed the petition. A habeas corpus case may end even after the court has issued the writ if the detained person himself appears before the Court, confirms that he knows his rights, and voluntarily asks to withdraw the petition. […]