A Defective Criminal Charge Is Not Always an Acquittal

A defective criminal information may be dismissed without ending the case if there is no merits acquittal, allowing prosecutors to refile a valid charge. A criminal case dismissed because the information fails to allege an essential element of the offense is not necessarily over. Where the dismissal is not based on the merits and contains […]

When New Procedural Rules Overtake a Pending Criminal Challenge

A procedural attack on preliminary investigation may fail when later legal changes validate the challenged prosecutor authority and procedure. People challenging a prosecutor’s authority in a pending criminal matter can lose the case when the very procedure they attack is later adopted as part of controlling law. In Litton v. Castillo, the Supreme Court treated […]

A Pending Tax Evasion Complaint Does Not Automatically Stop a Perjury Case

A pending administrative tax complaint does not suspend a perjury prosecution; Flordelis limits prejudicial questions to civil cases that determine criminal liability. A taxpayer or accuser cannot automatically pause a criminal perjury case simply because a related tax evasion issue is still pending before an administrative agency. For a prejudicial question to stop a criminal […]

Judges Must Explain Their Decisions: Why Bare Acquittals Can Still Lead to Discipline

Judges are presumed in good faith absent proof of bad faith, but decisions must state facts and law; unexplained judgments may trigger discipline. A judge may be spared from discipline for an allegedly wrong judgment when bad faith or gross incompetence is not proven, but the judge may still be admonished for issuing a decision […]

A Judge Cannot Force an Unrepresented Accused to Cross-Examine Witnesses

A judge was severely censured for forcing a non-lawyer accused to cross-examine witnesses and ordering reimbursement under threat of contempt. Courts may move cases forward, but speed cannot come at the expense of basic fairness: an accused person who is not a lawyer cannot be compelled to conduct his own cross-examination merely because his counsel […]

Newly Discovered Evidence Can Reopen a Criminal Conviction When It Casts Serious Doubt on Guilt

Newly discovered evidence may reopen a criminal conviction when it raises serious doubt on guilt and was unavailable at trial without the accused’s fault. A criminal conviction is not necessarily the final word when later evidence shows that the judgment may have rested on an incomplete record. In People v. Gensola, the Supreme Court applied […]

A Missed Brief Does Not Always Kill an Appeal on a Pure Question of Law

A timely appeal on a pure question of law may proceed despite procedural objections, especially where requiring certiorari would duplicate an appeal. A party who timely perfects an appeal on a pure question of law may still be allowed to proceed even if the record shows procedural imperfections, especially where requiring a separate certiorari petition […]