When Court Delay Is Not Neglect: The Supreme Court’s Practical Rule on eRaffle Backlogs and Administrative Liability

Court eRaffle delays do not automatically prove neglect; liability requires carelessness, bad faith, or breach of duty, but false surety clearances may still be punishable. Judges and court personnel are not automatically administratively liable simply because a new court technology causes case raffle delays. The decisive question is whether the delay was caused by carelessness, […]

Junk Shop Owners Can Be Convicted for Fencing Even Without Proof They Stole the Property

Junk shop owners may be convicted for fencing when stolen goods are found in their possession and suspicious circumstances show they should have known the source. Businesses that buy second-hand goods, scrap items, vehicle parts, or other movable property can face criminal liability for fencing when they possess stolen property under circumstances that should have […]

When an Irregular Government Loan Is Not Automatically Graft

Irregular LGU loan transactions are not automatically graft; prosecutors must prove gross and manifest disadvantage beyond reasonable doubt. Public officers are not guilty of graft merely because a government loan transaction was irregular, poorly documented, or later criticized as financially risky. To convict under the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act for entering into a contract […]

When a Private Person Can Be Dropped from a Graft Case for Lack of Conspiracy

Private persons cannot be tried for graft without probable cause of conspiracy with public officers; tax and corporate records helped defeat the charge. A private individual cannot be forced to stand trial for graft merely because prosecutors suspect ownership, influence, or benefit from a questioned government transaction. When the charge is violation of Section 3(e) […]

Grenade Evidence Must Survive Chain of Custody: Why a Valid Arrest Still Does Not Guarantee Conviction

A valid hot-pursuit arrest did not save an explosives conviction where police failed to prove chain of custody, but robbery was affirmed on credible eyewitness testimony. A criminal conviction can survive a warrantless hot-pursuit arrest and still fail if the prosecution cannot prove that the seized physical evidence was preserved, identified, and accounted for from […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Criminally Liable for Company Tax Debts

Corporate officers are not automatically criminally liable for company tax debts; prosecutors must prove personal responsibility and willful participation. A corporate title alone does not make an officer criminally liable for a company’s unpaid taxes. To convict a corporate officer for failure to pay taxes, prosecutors must prove not merely that the corporation had a […]

When Court Evidence Disappears: Lost Drug Exhibits Can Cost Court Personnel Their Careers

Court personnel may be dismissed when lost drug evidence compromises pending criminal cases, with clerks liable for gross neglect of duty. Court personnel who mishandle evidence can be dismissed from government service when their negligence compromises pending criminal cases, especially where the missing exhibits are the very drugs needed to prove the offense. For litigants, […]

Corporate Officers Can Face Criminal Trial for Blocking Stockholder Access to Company Records

Corporate officers may face trial for refusing stockholder access to records when the information sufficiently alleges unjustified refusal to inspect books. Corporate officers who refuse a stockholder’s lawful request to inspect company books cannot defeat a criminal case merely by arguing that the information did not recite every evidentiary detail. When an indictment alleges that […]

When Tax Structuring Becomes Evidence: Why Probable Cause Is Hard to Stop Before Trial

The Supreme Court upheld probable cause in a graft case, warning that tax-driven asset registration and ownership defenses are trial issues. Business owners, corporate officers, and politically exposed persons cannot defeat a graft prosecution at the preliminary investigation stage merely by presenting documents that dispute ownership, agency, or tax-driven structuring. Where the Ombudsman has evidence […]

Bouncing Checks, Corporate Officers, and the Notice Rule: When Personal Liability Survives a Corporate Signature

The Supreme Court held that B.P. 22 liability requires proof of notice of dishonor and that corporate officers may still face personal liability for bounced checks. Corporate officers who sign company checks cannot automatically escape personal exposure by invoking the corporation’s separate personality, especially when they personally undertook the obligation behind the checks. But a […]