A Wrong Caption Should Not Erase a Corporation’s Right to Recover Civil Liability

A corporation’s civil claim survives a wrong case caption when records show its interest and its officer’s authority in a B.P. 22-related dispute. A defective or changed case caption does not automatically defeat a corporation’s right to recover civil liability when the record clearly shows that the corporation was the real party affected and that […]

A Bad Investment Is Not Automatically Estafa: When Share Payments Stay Civil, Not Criminal

A failed share investment is not automatically estafa; prosecutors must prove fiduciary receipt and actual conversion before corporate officers may be convicted. Business losses, failed investments, and unpaid demands do not automatically become criminal estafa. When money is paid for shares of stock, prosecutors must still prove a fiduciary receipt of the money and a […]

Directors Are Not Criminally Liable for Government Loans Just Because They Sat on the Board

Directors are not criminally liable for alleged behest loans based on board membership alone; prosecutors must show specific participation and probable cause. Corporate directors and officers cannot be dragged into graft prosecution merely because they held office when a government-related loan was approved. For businesses, banks, government corporations, and taxpayers watching public fund investigations, the […]

When a Falsified Corporate Secretary’s Certificate Is Registered, the Criminal Clock Starts Running

Falsification charges over a corporate property sale were dismissed because prescription ran from registration of the secretary’s certificate. People accused of falsifying a notarized corporate document may still escape criminal punishment if the State files the case too late. The Lim ruling teaches a difficult but important rule: even where falsification of a public document […]

Corporate Officers Can Face Criminal Liability for Blocking a Member’s Right to Inspect Records

Corporate officers may face liability for refusing a member’s written demand to inspect records, even if the corporation’s registration was revoked. Corporate transparency is not optional: a member who makes a written demand to inspect association records may trigger personal criminal exposure for officers who refuse access without a lawful basis. For officers of corporations, […]

Corporate Dissolution Does Not End a Stockholder’s Right to Inspect Company Records

Corporate officers may still be liable for denying effective stockholder inspection of records during liquidation, even without clear malicious intent. Corporate officers cannot escape liability for denying a stockholder access to corporate books merely because the company has ceased operations or entered its winding-up period. A dissolved corporation remains alive for limited legal purposes, including […]

Tax Exemption Proof Rule: When Unsupported Tax-Free Claims Fail

Tax-free import claims must be clearly proven; unsupported exemption claims may allow BIR tax evasion and perjury charges to proceed. Taxpayers who claim that large transactions are tax-free must be ready to prove it with clear documents, because an unsupported claim of exemption may not stop a criminal tax case from proceeding. The Tax Exemption […]

When a Corporate Dispute Can Stop an Estafa Case Over Company Collections

Corporate authority disputes can suspend estafa cases when the validity of demand and alleged misappropriation depend on who may act for the corporation. A criminal estafa case over company money may be suspended when the accused’s alleged duty to turn over funds depends on a still-unresolved corporate authority dispute. For business owners, family corporations, property […]