When a Court Officer Acts as Civil Registrar, the Supreme Court May Not Be the Proper Disciplinary Forum

Supreme Court dismissed a complaint against a Shari’a clerk acting as civil registrar, holding discipline belonged to proper executive or civil service authorities. Administrative complaints against court personnel can fail before the merits are ever reached when the act complained of was performed under a separate, non-judicial function. In Mamiscal v. Abdullah, the Supreme Court […]

A Lawyer’s Private Life Can End a Legal Career When It Makes a Mockery of Marriage

The Supreme Court disbarred a lawyer who knowingly contracted a second marriage despite a subsisting first marriage, but dismissed charges against another lawyer for lack of proof. Lawyers may lose the right to practice law for private conduct that reveals a serious defect in moral character, especially when they knowingly use legal maneuvering to create […]

Judges Cannot Notarize the Same Cohabitation Affidavits They Rely On to Solemnize Marriage

Judges cannot notarize cohabitation affidavits they later rely on to solemnize license-free marriages; doing so is gross ignorance of the law. Parties relying on the five-year cohabitation exception to the marriage license requirement must have their affidavit sworn before a proper officer other than the judge who will solemnize the marriage. The ruling makes clear […]

When a Lawyer’s Private Misconduct Becomes Grounds for Disbarment

A lawyer was disbarred for contracting a second marriage while the first remained valid and for repeatedly defying Supreme Court orders. Lawyers may be removed from the profession not only for misconduct in court or in client matters, but also for private acts that show a lack of moral fitness to remain officers of the […]

Void Marriage Co-Ownership: Property Partition After Annulment

Property acquired during a void marriage may be partitioned as co-owned if titles show acquisition during the union and ownership is unrebutted. Void marriage co-ownership means that property acquired during a marriage later declared void may still be divided between the former spouses if the property was acquired during their union and the registered owner […]

Delay, Fear, and a Family Home Do Not Defeat a Rape Complaint When Testimony Remains Credible

The Supreme Court upheld a qualified rape conviction, ruling that delayed reporting, family setting, and minor inconsistencies do not defeat credible victim testimony. A rape conviction may rest on the credible testimony of the victim, even when the abuse happened inside a family home, even when the report was delayed, and even when the defense […]

A Child’s Clear Testimony Can Convict Even When the Accused Is Her Own Father

The Court affirmed a father’s rape conviction, holding that a child victim’s clear and credible testimony can overcome denial and prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A rape conviction may rest on the testimony of a child victim when her account is straightforward, candid, and credible, even if the accused argues that poor lighting, family pressure, […]

When a Judge Performs an Invalid Marriage, Administrative Liability Can Follow

A judge was fined for solemnizing a marriage outside his jurisdiction and without a license, showing how marriage defects can affect estate and benefit rights. A marriage solemnized by a judge outside his territorial authority, and without the required marriage license, can expose that judge to administrative discipline even when the ceremony was allegedly performed […]

When Separation Is Not Enough: Judges May Be Disciplined for Solemnizing a Bigamous Marriage

Long separation does not authorize remarriage. The Court disciplined a judge for solemnizing a void and bigamous marriage despite clear legal impediments. Couples who have long lived apart from their spouses cannot treat separation as a shortcut to remarriage, and a judge who solemnizes that later union may be administratively liable when the prior marriages […]

Muslim Estate Settlement: When Shari’a Courts Must Hear More Evidence

Muslim estate rights depend on the law in force when marriages, births, divorces, and property acquisitions occurred, not blanket assumptions. Muslim estate settlement cases cannot be decided by mechanical assumptions about marriage, property, and succession when the family history predates the Muslim Code and the record is incomplete. The doctrine clarified in Malang v. Judge […]