Judges cannot notarize cohabitation affidavits they later rely on to solemnize license-free marriages; doing so is gross ignorance of the law.
Parties relying on the five-year cohabitation exception to the marriage license requirement must have their affidavit sworn before a proper officer other than the judge who will solemnize the marriage. The ruling makes clear that a judge cannot both notarize the affidavit of cohabitation and then objectively examine that same affidavit as the basis for performing a marriage without a license.
The Practical Problem: License-Free Marriages and “Package” Solemnizations
Philippine law allows a narrow exception to the marriage license requirement. Under Article 34 of the Family Code, a man and woman who have lived together as husband and wife for at least five years, and who have no legal impediment to marry each other, may marry without a marriage license. But this exemption is not automatic. The contracting parties must state those facts in an affidavit before a person authorized by law to administer oaths. Separately, the solemnizing officer must also state under oath that he ascertained their qualifications and found no legal impediment to the marriage.
In Tupal v. Judge Rojo (A.M. No. MTJ-14-1842), the complaint arose from a Bacolod City judge who solemnized marriages without marriage licenses after notarizing the parties’ affidavits of cohabitation on the same day as the wedding. The complainant attached nine affidavits of cohabitation notarized by the judge. The practice was described as part of alleged “package marriages,” where the affidavit and the solemnization were handled together by the same judge.
The Core Rule: The Notary and the Solemnizing Judge Must Be Different Persons
The Supreme Court held that municipal trial court judges cannot notarize the affidavits of cohabitation of the very parties whose marriage they will solemnize. The Court treated the issue not as a mere technical notarial defect, but as a conflict between two distinct legal functions. The person who administers the oath for the affidavit of cohabitation performs one function. The solemnizing officer who examines that affidavit and determines whether the parties qualify for a license-free marriage performs another.
The Court reasoned that a judge cannot objectively examine a document that he himself notarized. If the affidavit later turns out to contain irregularities or false statements, the judge would be in the compromised position of having approved the oath and then relied on that same document to solemnize the marriage. That is precisely why Article 34 and the Guidelines on the Solemnization of Marriage by Members of the Judiciary assume two different persons: one authorized to administer the oath, and another acting as solemnizing officer.
Why the Affidavit of Cohabitation Is Not Part of the Judge’s Notarial Authority
Municipal trial court and municipal circuit trial court judges may act as notaries public ex officio, but only within strict limits. Circular No. 1-90 allows them to notarize documents connected with the exercise of their official functions and duties. It does not permit them to notarize private documents that bear no direct relation to their judicial functions. Judges may also act as notaries public ex officio only if lawyers or notaries public are lacking in their territorial jurisdiction, and they must certify that lack in the notarized document.
The Court held that an affidavit of cohabitation is not a document connected with the judge’s official function as a solemnizing officer. The judge’s official duty is to personally interview the parties, examine their submitted requirements, review the affidavit, and execute his own sworn statement that the requirements have been met. The duty to examine the affidavit does not include the authority to notarize it.
The judge argued that an affidavit of cohabitation serves a public purpose and is the counterpart of a marriage license. The Court rejected that argument. An affidavit remains a private document until notarized. Notarization is the act that converts it into a public document and makes it admissible in court without further proof of authenticity. Therefore, when the judge notarized the nine affidavits, he notarized private documents not connected with his official judicial functions.
Common Practice Is Not a Defense
One of the most important practical lessons of the ruling is that repeated local practice does not legalize an unlawful act. The judge argued that other judges in Bacolod City and Talisay City had also notarized affidavits of cohabitation for parties whose marriages they solemnized. The Court was unmoved. Violations of law are not excused by practice to the contrary.
For ordinary people, this matters because shortcuts in marriage documentation can create future legal uncertainty. A couple may believe that a marriage process is valid simply because it is commonly done in a local court. This decision warns that the legality of the process depends on statutory requirements, not convenience, habit, or the assurances of court personnel.
The Notarial Defect: Identity Must Be Properly Established
The Supreme Court also found that the judge violated the 2004 Rules on Notarial Practice. A notary cannot notarize a document unless the signatory is personally present and either personally known to the notary or identified through competent evidence of identity. In the nine affidavits, the judge merely stated that the parties subscribed and swore before him. He did not state that the parties were personally known to him or that they presented competent evidence of identity.
The judge claimed that he personally knew the parties because he interviewed them regarding their qualifications to marry. The Court rejected this. Personal appearance and interview are not the same as being personally known to the notary. The parties are expected to appear before the notary; that fact alone does not establish identity. To be personally known, the notary must at least be acquainted with the persons appearing before him. Otherwise, competent evidence of identity must be required.
Gross Ignorance of the Law and the Limits of Good Faith
The Court found the judge guilty of gross ignorance of the law. Good faith may protect a judge in situations involving difficult judgment calls, but it does not apply where the rules are basic and the legal requirements are evident. The limits on a judge’s ex officio notarial authority, the need to certify the lack of lawyers or notaries public, and the requirement of personal knowledge or competent evidence of identity are basic procedural safeguards.
Because the judge violated these requirements nine times, the Court held that the conduct could not be treated as mere error. The New Code of Judicial Conduct requires judges to ensure that their conduct is above reproach and perceived to be so by a reasonable observer. Ignorance of basic law, especially when repeated, reflects a failure of judicial integrity.
The Penalty and the Warning to Trial Courts
The Supreme Court suspended Judge Remegio V. Rojo from office for six months without salary and other benefits. While gross ignorance of the law may justify severe sanctions, the Court considered that he may have been misled by the practice of other judges in nearby areas. Still, the Court directed that copies of the resolution be served on all municipal trial courts in Bacolod City and Talisay City, signaling that similar violations would be dealt with strictly.
What This Means for Couples, Families, and Lawyers
For couples marrying under the five-year cohabitation exception, the lesson is straightforward: do not treat the affidavit of cohabitation as a formality. It should be sworn before a proper officer who is not the same judge who will solemnize the marriage. The solemnizing judge must then independently examine the affidavit, personally interview the parties, and execute the required sworn statement.
For families and litigants, the ruling is also important in disputes involving marriage validity, inheritance, property rights, benefits, and legitimacy. Defects in marriage documentation may later become relevant when a marriage is questioned in court, when heirs dispute succession rights, or when property acquired during the relationship becomes contested. While not every irregularity automatically voids a marriage, this case shows that courts take the legal safeguards surrounding license-free marriages seriously.
For lawyers and notaries, the decision is a reminder that notarization is not clerical work. It is a public function that affects the authenticity, admissibility, and reliability of documents. The notary must confirm identity, ensure personal appearance, and comply with the Rules on Notarial Practice. A defective jurat or casual approach to identity verification can carry serious consequences.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in civil litigation, family law disputes, notarial compliance concerns, property conflicts, inheritance issues, and court-related proceedings where document validity and procedural regularity matter. If you are dealing with a questioned affidavit, a disputed marriage record, an inheritance conflict, or a litigation issue involving defective notarization, our lawyers can help assess the legal risks and available remedies. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult a Makati-based litigation and dispute resolution team.