When a Contractor’s Worker Is Not Your Employee: The Supreme Court’s Payroll-and-Control Rule for Job Contracting Disputes

A contractor’s worker was not Petrophil’s employee because Gersher hired and paid him; transfer and demotion were upheld absent unfair labor practice. A company that receives services from a contractor is not automatically the worker’s employer simply because the work is performed inside its premises. Where the records show that the contractor hired the worker, […]

Employers Cannot Fire an Employee for the Alleged Misconduct of a Spouse

An employee cannot be dismissed for a spouse’s alleged misconduct. The Court awarded separation pay and backwages instead of reinstatement. An employee may not be dismissed simply because her spouse is accused of immoral or wrongful conduct. For employers, schools, and religious institutions, the ruling establishes a practical boundary: workplace discipline must be anchored on […]

Overtime Pay Is Not Automatic: Employees Must Prove Authorized Work Beyond Office Hours

Employees must prove authorized overtime work, but employers may owe backwages when preventive suspension lacks a serious and imminent threat. Employees claiming overtime pay must do more than show that they stayed late, missed a time-out entry, or worked during a period when overtime was generally possible; they must prove that the overtime work was […]

When a Strike Ends, Who Must Take Workers Back? The Supreme Court Draws the Line on Backwages and Successor Liability

Supreme Court limits backwage liability after a strike while allowing re-admission remedies and specific wage claims against the proper parties. Workers who are unfairly refused re-admission after a strike may recover backwages, but the Supreme Court made one critical limitation clear: liability does not automatically follow every company that later takes over operations, especially where […]

When Project-Based Retrenchment and Loss of Trust Justify Dismissal

The Court upheld a project engineer’s dismissal, ruling that labor due process requires a fair opportunity to be heard, not endless extensions or delayed filings. Employers may lawfully terminate project personnel when the work has substantially ended and management has lost confidence in an employee whose competence and integrity have been called into question, so […]

When Labor Picketing Spills Over to a Neighboring Business, the RTC May Step In

A non-employer affected by strike activity may seek RTC relief when no labor dispute or employment relationship is shown with the union. A business that is not proven to be the employer of striking workers may ask the regular courts for relief when picketing or strike activity affects its premises. The key practical lesson is […]

No Second Bite at Certiorari: Final Supreme Court Rulings Bind Parties Who Already Had Their Day in Court

The Court dismissed a repeat certiorari petition because the same administrative decision had already been reviewed, reinforcing finality in tax and labor disputes. A party cannot keep relitigating the same administrative decision by changing procedural posture or filing a new petition after the Supreme Court has already passed upon the issue. For taxpayers, employers, unions, […]

Ignoring a Court Order Is Not Cured by Partial Payment or Good Intentions

Partial compliance and good faith did not purge contempt where a lawyer failed to fully obey a court order to account for disputed labor-case proceeds. A party held in contempt cannot escape punishment by making partial payment, offering explanations, or invoking good faith after failing to fully obey a clear court directive. The practical lesson […]