Government-Owned Subsidiaries Cannot Escape Labor Law When Employees Are Illegally Dismissed

Employees of GOCC subsidiaries without original charters may sue before labor tribunals when dismissed without due process, reinstatement, and backwages. Employees of government-owned or controlled corporations organized under the general corporation law are not automatically civil service employees; when they are dismissed without due process, their remedy may still lie before labor tribunals, with reinstatement, […]

Tax Returns Alone Cannot Justify Retrenchment: Employers Must Prove Real Business Losses Before Dismissing Workers

Tax returns alone did not save a retrenchment defense. The Court restored reinstatement and backwages after workers were denied a fair chance to contest late evidence. Employees retrenched for alleged business losses may challenge the dismissal when the employer relies on financial documents presented only on appeal and without giving workers a fair chance to […]

Tax Withholding Does Not Automatically Make Someone an Employee

Tax withholding alone does not prove employment. The Court applied the control test and protected an agent with business interest from arbitrary revocation. Tax treatment can be powerful evidence in a labor or commercial dispute, but it does not end the inquiry: a person who receives commissions, operates through her own clientele, and bears business […]

Labor Disputes with Damage Claims Belong Before Labor Arbiters, Not Regular Courts

Damage claims tied to unfair labor practice remain within labor arbiter jurisdiction, even when pleaded as civil tort claims or linked to a corporate merger. Employees and unions cannot move an unfair labor practice case to a regular court simply by asking for damages, injunction, or civil-law remedies. When the injury arises from alleged interference […]

Labor Priority Limits: When Wages Do Not Always Beat Tax Liens

Unpaid wage claims get first preference only over free property, not over specific tax liens; insolvency priorities still follow Civil Code rules in liquidation. The Labor Priority Limits doctrine matters whenever an employer becomes insolvent: unpaid workers may have a powerful statutory preference, but that preference does not automatically wipe out existing tax liens, customs […]

Old Employee Money Claims Can Expire Fast: The One-Year Labor Code Transition Rule

Old employee money claims may be barred by prescription. The Court dismissed a delayed illegal dismissal and reimbursement claim under the Labor Code transition rule. Employees whose salary, separation pay, reimbursement, or illegal dismissal claims arose before the Labor Code took effect could not wait indefinitely to sue; for those pre-Code money claims, the Court […]

When Wage Claims Must Go to the Labor Arbiter, Not the Regional Director

Employee wage and benefit claims filed as money claims must be heard by the labor arbiter, not decided by a regional director without jurisdiction. Employers facing employee claims for unpaid wages, 13th month pay, or service incentive leave pay may question the forum when the case is filed before a labor regional director instead of […]

A Missed Service Copy Should Not Kill a Worker’s Labor Appeal

A worker’s NLRC appeal should not be dismissed for a non-prejudicial failure to serve a copy when substantial justice requires review on the merits. A labor appeal should not be dismissed on a purely technical defect when the worker timely filed the appeal, acted in good faith, and the missing copy to the employer did […]

Union Election Protests Must First Be Fought Inside the Union, Not Before Labor Officials

Union election disputes must generally pass through internal union remedies first; labor authorities cannot intervene absent a true intra-union conflict. Union members and officers cannot automatically bring every disputed union election to labor authorities. When the controversy is essentially about ballots, internal protest rules, and the union’s own election machinery, the first battleground is the […]