When Illness Appears During Employment, the Employer Must Prove It Is Not Work-Related

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer proves otherwise, protecting workers in sickness and disability claims. Employees who become sick while still in service are not required to prove with mathematical certainty that their work caused the illness. Under the compensability presumption applied in Dimdiman, once the illness supervenes during employment, the […]

Work-Related Illness Benefits Cannot Be Arbitrarily Reduced Without Evidence

A work-related illness award cannot be reduced without evidence. Jacoba restored full medical reimbursement for a public school teacher. Employees who prove that an illness is work-connected may recover compensable medical expenses, and an agency cannot simply reduce an award without a clear evidentiary basis. The practical rule from Jacoba is direct: once the compensability […]

When Absences Are Not Enough to Fire a Long-Serving Employee

Repeated absences may justify discipline, but not always dismissal. Long service and proportionality can reduce termination to suspension with back wages. Employers may discipline workers for repeated absences, but dismissal can be struck down when the penalty is grossly disproportionate to the offense, especially where the employee has long service and the surrounding facts suggest […]

When Government Agencies Overreach, Courts Can Stop Them

Administrative agencies cannot use contempt powers to punish a party for seeking court relief. The ruling protects judicial review against agency overreach. Government officials cannot use contempt powers to punish a person for going to court. When an agency acts beyond the authority granted by law, a court may intervene through prohibition and injunction, even […]

Labor Officials Cannot Outsource Union Election Appeals to a Private Federation

Labor officials must decide certification election appeals themselves and cannot refer adjudication to a private federation, protecting workers from union election delay. Workers and employers in certification election disputes are entitled to a decision from the labor agency itself, not from a private labor federation. The ruling establishes a strict non-delegation rule in representation cases: […]

Reinstatement Does Not Always Mean Backwages: When Labor Tribunals Must Explain Why Pay Is Denied

Reinstatement does not always mean backwages, but labor tribunals must explain any denial with clear facts, especially in abandonment or transfer disputes. Employees who win reinstatement do not automatically win backwages in every labor dispute, but a labor tribunal cannot deny backwages through a bare or ambiguous order. When the record is thin, especially where […]

When Labor Arbiters Can Award Moral Damages for Illegal Dismissal

Labor arbiters may decide moral and exemplary damages when they arise from illegal dismissal, avoiding split proceedings between labor tribunals and courts. Employees who are illegally dismissed may pursue not only backwages or separation pay, but also moral and exemplary damages before labor authorities when those damages arise from the manner and consequences of the […]

When an Employer Knows an Employee Is Sick, Silence Can Waive Its Defenses

Employer knowledge of a worker’s illness can trigger the duty to timely controvert a compensation claim; silence may waive key defenses. An employer that knows its worker has become disabled or has died cannot wait, stay silent, and later defeat a compensation claim by saying it was not formally informed. Under the Supreme Court’s ruling […]

Years Worked Before the Labor Code Still Count for Retirement Pay

The Supreme Court held that pre-Labor Code service may count in retirement pay when labor welfare rules protect long-serving employees. Employees who reached retirement age after the Labor Code took effect could claim retirement benefits based on their actual length of service, not merely from the date the Labor Code became effective. For employers, the […]

Foremen Can Vote in Union Certification Elections Unless True Managerial Authority Is Proven

Foremen may vote in union certification elections unless actual managerial authority is proven; job titles alone cannot defeat labor representation rights. Workers with supervisory-sounding titles do not automatically lose their right to participate in union certification elections. Employers and rival unions must prove real managerial authority, not merely job labels or routine shop-floor responsibility, before […]