When Illness Strikes at Work, Employers Must Prove It Is Not Work-Related

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer proves otherwise, shifting the burden in workplace compensation disputes. An employee who becomes ill while still employed does not always carry the full burden of proving exactly how work caused the illness. Under the compensability presumption applied in Tambasen, once the illness supervenes during employment, […]

Union-Requested Dismissals Still Require Due Process: Employers Cannot Fire Workers Blindly

Employers cannot automatically dismiss workers on a union’s request; due process remains required, with reinstatement and backwages for bad-faith termination. Employers cannot hide behind a union request or a maintenance-of-membership clause to dismiss workers without first giving them a fair chance to be heard. When management acts hastily, ignores the circumstances behind a union expulsion, […]

When Illness Appears During Work, the Burden Shifts to the Employer

The Court reinforced presumed compensability for illnesses arising during employment and barred employers from belated defenses after non-controversion. Workers and their families do not lose compensation claims merely because an illness is difficult to trace with mathematical certainty. When sickness, disability, or death arises during covered employment, the law may presume compensability, and the employer […]

Piece-Rate Workers May Still Be Employees: The Control Test in Philippine Labor Law

Piece-rate and pakyaw workers may still be employees when the business controls how work is done, affecting unfair labor practice and backwage claims. Workers paid by the piece, called only when work is available, or compensated under the familiar pakyaw arrangement may still be regular employees if the business retains the right to control how […]

No Employer-Employee Relationship, No Workmen’s Compensation Liability: Why Business Owners Are Not Automatically Personally Liable

A worker’s death may be compensable, but liability falls on the proven employer. The Court cleared an individual wrongly held personally liable. Workmen’s compensation liability follows the employer-employee relationship, not mere ownership labels, family assumptions, or a claimant’s decision to name a convenient individual respondent. For business owners, operators, and managers, the practical lesson is […]

When Absences Are Used as a Pretext: Union Activity Can Make a Dismissal Illegal

The Court held that absences cannot justify dismissal when the real motive is union activity, and a good-faith unfair labor practice strike is not illegal. Employers cannot rely on a worker’s absences as a shield if the real reason for dismissal is union activity. The practical rule is simple but powerful: a company may have […]

When Government Review Can Revive a Dismissed Employee Appeal

The Court upheld presidential review of a labor appeal and sustained dismissal of a managerial employee for loss of confidence based on a concrete breach of trust. A labor appeal is not defeated simply because the employee describes the ruling as contrary to law, unsupported by evidence, or gravely injurious to his rights. When the […]

Loss of Confidence Is Not a Shortcut to Fire Employees Without Proof

Employers cannot dismiss ordinary employees on vague loss-of-confidence grounds; Central Textile required proof, due process, and reinstatement when theft was unproven. An employer cannot convert an unproven accusation of theft into a lawful dismissal by calling it loss of confidence. For ordinary employees, security of tenure means that livelihood cannot be taken away on suspicion, […]

When an Employer Partly Pays a Judgment, It Cannot Later Invoke a Stay to Avoid the Rest

Employers that partly implement an appealed labor judgment cannot later invoke a stay to avoid linked deductions such as approved attorney’s liens. An employer that voluntarily implements part of an appealed labor judgment may be barred from using the appeal as a shield against related obligations flowing from that same judgment. For government institutions, corporations, […]