A Payroll Settlement Is Not a Waiver of Disability Compensation

A labor settlement for wage-related claims does not automatically waive a separate disability compensation claim when illness supervenes during employment. Employers cannot treat a labor settlement for unpaid wages, salary increases, bonuses, or living allowances as an automatic release of a separate disability compensation claim. When an employee’s illness supervenes during employment, the compensability presumption […]

When a Worker Dies on the Job, the Employer Must Rebut Compensability

Employee death during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer rebuts it. The Court restored death benefits for the worker’s family. Families of employees who die while still in the service of their employer are not required to prove every possible causal link between the death and the job before receiving compensation. Where death occurs […]

When Work Aggravates Illness, Employers May Still Owe Compensation Even Without Total Disability

Work-related illness may be compensable when employment aggravates the condition, even without total disability or perfect procedural filing by the employee. Employees who become ill while in service may recover workmen’s compensation when their work aggravated or accelerated the illness, even if the disease was not originally caused by the job and even if the […]

When Non-Union Employees Cannot Be Charged Union Lawyer’s Fees

Non-union supervisors who received employer-extended wage increases could not be charged union lawyer’s fees without representation, consent, or CBA coverage. Employees who receive wage increases because their employer voluntarily extends benefits across the company cannot automatically be made to pay the union lawyer who negotiated those benefits for another group. The doctrine is simple but […]

When a Government Worker’s Final Compensation Award Cannot Be Reversed Later

A final workmen’s compensation award for a government gardener with tuberculosis could not be reversed after the review period expired. A final compensation award in favor of an injured or sick worker cannot be undone by a tribunal that has already lost jurisdiction over the case. For employees, especially those serving in government offices, the […]

When a Worker Keeps Working Despite Illness, Medical Benefits May Still Be Due

A sick employee who kept working was denied disability pay but still received medical and rehabilitation benefits for work-connected illness. A government employee who continues reporting for work despite a work-connected illness may lose the basis for wage-loss disability pay, but not necessarily the right to medical reimbursement, rehabilitation services, and related benefits. The Corales […]

When a Work Injury Award Becomes Final, the Agency Cannot Reopen Liability

A teacher’s work injury award was reinstated after the Commission wrongly reopened compensability when only the amount of disability benefits was under review. When a compensation award has become final on the issue of compensability, the reviewing body cannot later erase the claim by deciding an issue the parties no longer raised. For injured workers […]

When an Employee Falls Ill at Work, Technical Defaults Cannot Defeat Compensation Claims

Employee illness during work is presumed compensable when the employer fails to timely controvert, but benefits depend on the specific claim filed. Employees and their families may still recover workmen’s compensation even when a claim has procedural defects, especially where the employer knew of the illness, failed to timely controvert the claim, and the record […]

When Employers Stay Silent, Workers’ Compensation Claims Can Become Practically Unanswerable

Employers that fail to timely contest work injury claims may waive defenses, allowing death benefits when compensability is presumed. Employers who fail to timely contest a work injury or death claim may lose more than a procedural deadline: they may forfeit the right to dispute compensability itself. In Caleb, the Court treated the employer’s silence […]

When an Employer Fails to Contest a Compensation Claim on Time, It May Lose the Right to Fight It

Failure to timely contest a worker’s compensation claim can waive employer defenses and support disability and death benefits for the worker’s heirs. Employers that ignore or delay contesting a workmen’s compensation claim may lose the right to dispute it altogether, including the right to argue that the illness or death was not work-related. For employees […]