A Renewed CBA Cannot Block a Certification Election When It Was Signed Too Early

A prematurely renewed CBA cannot block a certification election when it frustrates employees’ right to choose their bargaining representative. Rank-and-file employees cannot be locked into a bargaining representative by a collective bargaining agreement rushed into existence before the law’s certification-election window. When management and an incumbent union renew a CBA ahead of the prescribed freedom […]

When Work-Related Illness Claims Are Filed Late, Disability—not First Diagnosis—Starts the Clock

The Supreme Court held that occupational illness claims prescribe from disability to work, not first diagnosis, and doubts favor the worker. Workers who become disabled by an occupational illness are not automatically barred from compensation merely because the disease was noticed years earlier. For workmen’s compensation claims involving progressive illnesses, the decisive date is when […]

A Criminal Settlement Does Not Erase an Employer’s Compensation Liability

A worker’s family may still claim statutory death benefits despite settling with the third-party offender who caused the fatal workplace accident. A worker’s family may still recover statutory death benefits from the employer even after receiving money from the third party who caused the fatal accident. A criminal settlement with the offender is not automatically […]

When Illness Strikes During Employment, Compensation Is Presumed Unless the Employer Proves Otherwise

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer rebuts it; uncertainty in a medical report did not defeat the parents’ claim. Employees and their families may recover workmen’s compensation when an illness appears during employment, even if the exact medical cause is unknown, unless the employer presents evidence strong enough to defeat the […]

When a Workmen’s Compensation Claim Fails Despite Illness During Employment

Illness during employment may be presumed work-related, but compensation can fail when medical evidence shows no work connection, aggravation, or disability. An employee’s illness does not automatically become compensable merely because it appeared while the employee was still working. Where medical evidence shows that the condition was neither caused nor aggravated by the work, and […]

When Workplace Conditions Aggravate an Illness, Medical Benefits May Still Be Owed

A worker whose asthma was aggravated by hospital duties could recover medical benefits, but not disability compensation without loss of earning capacity. Workers whose illness is aggravated by the conditions of their employment may still be entitled to medical reimbursement and treatment benefits, even if they continued receiving salary during sick leave and even if […]

When Employers Stay Silent, Workers’ Compensation Defenses Can Be Lost

A delayed employer controversion waived defenses to a worker’s disability claim, where illness during employment triggered a presumption of compensability. A worker who develops an illness while performing dusty, cold, or physically taxing work does not have to prove his case like an ordinary civil lawsuit before compensation may be granted. Under the old Workmen’s […]

When Illness Strikes at Work, Compensation May Be Presumed

Illness contracted during employment is presumed compensable; Castro restored disability benefits after work aggravated tuberculosis and heart disease under compensation law. Workers who become ill during employment may invoke a powerful presumption: unless the employer can overcome it, the illness is treated as compensable when it was contracted in the course of work. For employees, […]

Clerical Error Corrections in Court Judgments: When a Peso Difference Still Matters

A clerical error in a judgment’s dispositive portion may be corrected so the payable administrative fee reflects the legally intended amount. A clerical mistake in a judgment does not become law simply because it appears in the dispositive portion. When the record shows that a figure was written incorrectly, the court may correct the judgment […]

When Employers Miss the Deadline, Work Injury Claims Can Become Much Harder to Defeat

Illness arising during employment may be presumed compensable, and employers who fail to timely controvert can waive defenses against the claim. Employers who fail to timely controvert a workmen’s compensation claim may lose key defenses, and illnesses that appear during employment may be presumed compensable unless the employer can prove otherwise with substantial evidence. For […]