When a Government Employer Misses the Appeal Deadline, a Compensation Award Becomes Final

A government employer lost its challenge to a disability award after missing the appeal deadline, confirming that final compensation awards bind public agencies. A government employer cannot defeat an employee’s compensation award by filing a late petition for relief after the award has already become final. The decisive rule is simple but powerful: once the […]

No Notice, No Compensation Award: Due Process Still Controls Labor Claims

A compensation award was set aside because the record failed to show service, notice, or hearing, preserving due process while allowing the claim to proceed. Employers may challenge a labor compensation award when the record does not show that they were served with the claim, notified of the proceedings, and given a real opportunity to […]

When Illness Strikes at Work, the Employer Must Prove It Was Not Work-Connected

Illness or injury arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer proves otherwise with substantial evidence. Employees who became ill or injured while their workmen’s compensation claims were still governed by the old Workmen’s Compensation Act gained a powerful protection from the Aninias line of cases: once sickness or injury arose during employment, compensability […]

When Employers Miss the Deadline, Work Injury Claims Become Much Harder to Defeat

Illness arising during employment is presumed work-related, and an employer that fails to timely controvert may waive defenses to compensation. An employee who becomes ill while still in service does not always have to prove, from scratch, that the job caused the illness. Under the workmen’s compensation presumption applied in Ferrer, an illness that supervened […]

When Work Aggravates Illness: Employees May Still Recover Compensation Even If the Disease Has Personal Causes

Employees may recover compensation for illness aggravated by work, even if personal factors contributed, when the disease arose during employment. Workers who develop an illness while performing long-term duties may recover workmen’s compensation even when the disease also has personal or dietary causes, so long as employment contributed even in a small degree to the […]

When a Labor Case Becomes Moot, Courts Will Not Decide It Just to Settle the Argument

A labor prohibition case was dismissed as moot after the parties no longer needed a ruling on the certification election dispute. A party asking a court to stop an ongoing labor proceeding may lose the case without any ruling on the merits if later events make the dispute academic. The practical lesson is simple but […]

When a Strike Injunction Case Becomes Moot: Why Courts Will Not Decide Labor Disputes After the Controversy Has Passed

A strike injunction challenge was dismissed as moot after later events overtook the dispute, leaving no live controversy for the Supreme Court to decide. Courts do not decide labor injunction disputes merely to settle a past argument. When a strike, picketing controversy, or restraining order has lost its practical effect because later events have overtaken […]

When a Government Employee’s Work Illness Claim Cannot Be Defeated by a Filing Technicality

A government employee’s work-illness claim survived a wrong-forum appeal because the employer admitted work connection and failed to controvert compensation. A worker’s compensation claim should not be thrown out simply because an appeal was filed in the wrong office when no party was prejudiced, especially where the employer did not controvert the illness and even […]

Illegal Strike Does Not Automatically Mean Workers Can Be Fired

Illegal strike participation does not automatically justify dismissal; employers must prove individual misconduct before terminating workers. Workers who join an illegal strike do not automatically lose their jobs simply because the strike was later declared unlawful. For employers, the ruling draws an important line: the illegality of a work stoppage may justify court intervention against […]

Retrenchment Cannot Be Used as a Cover for Union Busting

Retrenchment cannot shield union-busting dismissals. The Court upheld reinstatement and back wages where layoffs followed union organizing and lacked genuine business basis. Employers who label dismissals as retrenchment must be ready to prove that the job cuts were genuine, business-driven, and fairly applied; when the timing, conduct, and surrounding facts show that the real motive […]