A Union Can Leave Its Federation Without Losing Its Legal Personality

A registered local union keeps its legal personality after disaffiliation, and a later CBA cannot defeat a pending certification election. A local union does not lose its legal personality merely because it disaffiliates from its mother federation or changes its name. For employers and competing unions, the practical consequence is direct: a pending representation dispute […]

When a Denied Government Employee Death Benefit Is Later Approved, the Court Will Not Keep the Case Alive

A widow’s denied workmen’s compensation claim became moot after later agency approval, reaffirming liberal construction of employee benefit laws. A widow who continues fighting a denied workmen’s compensation claim may still obtain relief when the compensation agency later changes course and approves payment; once that happens, the Supreme Court will not continue deciding an appeal […]

When Cross-Examination Is Denied, Labor Evidence Can Collapse

Untested testimony cannot support dismissal in labor cases; employers must prove suspension grounds or face reinstatement and limited back wages. A party in a labor case cannot be made to lose property, employment rights, or back wages on the strength of testimony it never had a fair chance to test. The Cross-Examination Completion Doctrine means […]

When Illness Appears During Employment, Compensation Claims Become Harder to Defeat

Illness that arises during employment is presumed compensable, allowing a factory worker with epilepsy to recover disability benefits despite employer objections. An employee who becomes ill while working may be entitled to disability compensation even when the employer disputes the connection between the job and the sickness. The doctrine is simple but powerful: when an […]

Habeas Corpus Still Matters Even After Release: Why Temporary Detention Can Trigger Court Review

Habeas corpus may become moot after release, but courts can still condemn restraints that unlawfully restrict liberty and labor union participation. Unlawful restraint does not become harmless merely because the government later releases the detainees. When liberty is curtailed without a clear lawful basis, habeas corpus remains a powerful remedy that can force officials to […]

Workmen’s Compensation Claims Cannot Be Defeated by Missing Marriage Papers Alone

A widow’s compensation claim cannot be denied solely for missing marriage papers when employer records and other evidence substantially prove marriage and dependency. A widow claiming workmen’s compensation benefits cannot be denied relief merely because she cannot produce the original marriage contract, where the employer’s own report, a death certificate, a parish certification, affidavits, and […]

Employers Cannot Block a Union Vote by Turning Signature Disputes Into Technical Objections

Employers cannot block a certification election through technical signature objections when the labor authority finds voting is the best test of employee choice. Employers facing a certification election petition cannot defeat the workers’ choice of bargaining representative by relying on technical objections to the union’s initial signature count when the labor authority has sufficient basis […]

When Illness Strikes at Work: Employees Can Recover Compensation Even After Returning to the Job

Employees may recover temporary disability compensation for illness during employment, even after returning to work, if the employer fails to rebut compensability. An employee who becomes ill during employment may still recover workmen’s compensation even if she later gets well enough to return to work. The decisive point is not whether the employee permanently lost […]

When Illness Appears at Work, Compensation Cannot Be Denied by Speculation

Illness during employment may be presumed compensable once a work link appears, shifting the burden to the employer to disprove work connection. An employee who becomes ill during the period of employment does not have to prove the full medical mechanics of how the job caused the disease before compensation may be awarded. Once a […]

Sick Workers Do Not Lose Compensation Just Because They Try to Earn Money for Medicine

A sick worker who drives occasionally to buy medicine does not lose compensation when work conditions caused or aggravated pulmonary tuberculosis. A worker who becomes ill from conditions linked to his job does not automatically lose compensation merely because he later tries to earn money while sick. Where illness appears during employment and the employer […]