When Government Instrumentalities Can Refuse Local Real Property Tax Assessments

Government instrumentalities with corporate powers are exempt from local real property tax unless taxable beneficial use is alleged and proven. Government instrumentalities with corporate powers are not automatically taxable by cities and municipalities simply because they own property, exercise business-like powers, or deal with private concessionaires. For real property tax to attach, the local government […]

Local Tax Ordinance Appeals: When City Tax Hikes Exceed LGC Limits

Cities cannot impose accumulated local tax hikes beyond LGC limits; taxpayers must challenge illegal ordinances through the proper appeal route. Local governments cannot wait years, accumulate unused taxing power, and then impose a one-time business tax increase beyond the Local Government Code’s 10 percent adjustment ceiling. For retailers and other businesses facing new city revenue […]

Local Business Tax Double Taxation: When LGUs Must Refund Excess Taxes

LGUs cannot impose duplicative local business taxes on the same activity; taxpayers may protest, pay, and sue for refund within strict deadlines. Local business taxpayers who are assessed twice for the same privilege of doing business may protest, pay to avoid business disruption, and still sue for a refund if they act within the strict […]

Void Ordinance Rule: When LGU Franchise Taxes Cannot Be Collected

LGUs cannot collect franchise taxes under a void municipal ordinance; later cityhood does not cure the invalid local tax assessment. Local governments cannot collect taxes from businesses unless the tax is imposed through a valid ordinance enacted by an LGU that had legal authority to impose that tax at the time of enactment. Under the […]

Initial Local Tax Implementation Rule: Limits on City Tax Hikes

Cities may correct old local tax codes, but retailer tax hikes must follow Local Government Code limits and cannot be oppressive. The Initial Local Tax Implementation Rule protects both sides of a local tax dispute: cities may correct outdated business tax ordinances to comply with the Local Government Code, but they cannot use that correction […]

Local Fiscal Autonomy Rule: When Congress Cannot Divert LGU Taxes

LGU tax proceeds must accrue to the LGU; Congress cannot divert locally imposed amusement taxes to FDCP or private film producers. Local taxes collected under the Local Government Code must accrue to the local government that levies them, and Congress cannot make an LGU impose a tax only to divert the proceeds to a national […]

Public Airport Properties Are Not Ordinary Taxable Real Estate

Public airport properties used for public purposes are exempt from local real property tax, except portions leased to private taxable entities. Local governments cannot treat public airport runways, terminals, taxiways, and airfields as ordinary taxable real estate when those properties are actually, solely, and exclusively used for public purposes. The Supreme Court clarified that an […]

Local Business Tax Double Taxation: When Manila Must Refund Taxes

Local governments cannot impose duplicate local business taxes on the same business privilege; unlawfully collected taxes must be refunded. Local business tax double taxation gives businesses a refund remedy when a city taxes the same privilege of doing business twice for the same purpose, in the same taxing period, and under the same taxing authority. […]

Regulatory Fee vs Local Tax: When LGU Charges Are Not Taxes

LGU infrastructure fees are not taxes when regulation is the primary purpose, and unsupported constitutional attacks on ordinances will fail. The Regulatory Fee vs Local Tax Rule matters because not every charge imposed by a city or municipality is a tax. A business that builds, installs, or maintains physical infrastructure may face local fees that […]

CTA Certiorari Power: Where Local Tax Disputes Must Be Fought

Local tax certiorari petitions from RTC interlocutory orders belong in the CTA, not the Court of Appeals, avoiding split jurisdiction. Local tax disputes do not always belong in the Court of Appeals: when a Regional Trial Court issues an interlocutory order in a local tax case, the proper court to review that order by certiorari […]