When a National Permit Cannot Take Away a Municipal Revenue Service

A municipal ferry service cannot be displaced by a transport certificate issued without direct notice, especially where local revenue powers are affected. Municipal governments with statutory authority over local ferry services cannot be stripped of that revenue-generating function by an administrative transport certificate issued without direct notice and hearing. The ruling matters for local tax […]

Metro Manila Rules Can Stand Even Without Separate City Referendums

Metro Manila may be treated as a special regulatory class, allowing unified governance when regional conditions justify different rules for businesses and taxpayers. Metro Manila-wide government action is not unconstitutional merely because it treats the metropolis differently from ordinary cities and municipalities. Where population density, shared services, traffic, utilities, public works, and regional administration create […]

When a Tax Sale Case Creates Doubt About Judicial Impartiality, the Judge Must Step Aside

Judges in local tax sale disputes may be required to inhibit when serious circumstances create reasonable doubt about impartiality and court fairness. Courts handling tax delinquency and local tax sale disputes must not only be legally correct; they must also appear impartial. When a judge’s continued handling of a case reasonably creates suspicion that fairness […]

Reelection Does Not Erase Criminal Liability for Public Officials Facing Graft Charges

Reelection may affect administrative penalties, but it does not erase criminal liability for graft. Civil rulings also do not automatically defeat prosecution. Public officials cannot rely on reelection, related civil-case rulings, or procedural shortcuts in suspension hearings to escape criminal prosecution for alleged graft. The ruling draws a sharp line between political accountability and criminal […]

When Government-Owned Property Cannot Be Forfeited for Local Real Property Taxes

Government-owned SSS property could not be forfeited for Bacolod realty taxes because public ownership, not proprietary use, controlled the exemption. Government-owned land and buildings are not automatically taxable merely because they are used by a public agency for operational or proprietary purposes. Where the law exempts property owned by the Republic from real property tax, […]

When Local Ordinances Overreach: Why Cities and Municipalities Cannot Penalize What National Law Does Not Allow

Municipal ordinances cannot impose penalties or restrictions that conflict with national law. The ruling shows how businesses may challenge invalid LGU enforcement actions. Local governments may regulate local affairs, but they cannot create fines, penalties, or enforcement schemes that contradict national law. For businesses, transport operators, delivery fleets, and taxpayers dealing with local permits and […]