When Public Utility Disputes Belong in Court, Not the SEC

Water consumers may sue in regular courts to compel statutory dissolution of a local water district; the dispute is not an SEC intra-corporate case. Consumers challenging the dissolution or alleged mismanagement of a local water district are not automatically confined to corporate remedies before the Securities and Exchange Commission. When the dispute concerns a quasi-public […]

Cement Tax Exemption Rule: Why Local Business Taxes Still Apply

Cement is a manufactured product, not a mineral product; mining tax exemptions do not bar local business taxes on cement sales and exports. The Cement Tax Exemption Rule warns manufacturers that a tax exemption for mining or mineral products does not automatically shield the downstream manufacture and export of cement from local business taxes. For […]

Local Business Tax Power: When LGUs May Tax Petroleum Companies

LGUs may tax petroleum business activity despite national product taxes, but unsupported storage fees and prescribed assessments may be defeated. Local business tax power means that a municipality may tax the business activity of a petroleum manufacturer even when the petroleum product itself is already subject to national specific tax, unless Congress clearly provides otherwise. […]

PAGCOR’s Tax Exemption Survives: Why Local Governments Cannot Tax National Gaming Operations

PAGCOR’s charter tax exemption bars local governments from imposing taxes or fees that would frustrate Congress’s national policy on gaming regulation. Local governments cannot impose taxes, fees, or regulatory charges on PAGCOR’s gaming operations when Congress has placed those operations under a national charter and expressly exempted them from local taxation. For businesses and public […]

When Government Corporations Still Owe Local Property Taxes

Government corporations may still owe local real property taxes when specific tax laws authorize court collection and later laws withdraw exemptions. Government-owned and controlled corporations cannot assume that public ownership alone shields their land, buildings, and facilities from local real property taxes. When a special real property tax law authorizes collection by local governments, courts […]

When Tax Exemptions Return Too Late: Why Government Corporations Can Still Owe Real Property Taxes

Restored tax exemptions do not erase real property taxes that accrued while an exemption was withdrawn; NAPOCOR remained liable to Albay. A restored tax exemption does not automatically erase taxes that already became collectible before the restoration took effect. For government-owned or controlled corporations, this ruling matters because even a powerful statutory exemption from real […]

Autonomous Regional Bodies Must Still Follow Due Process Before Removing Their Own Officials

Autonomous regional bodies may manage internal affairs, but removal or expulsion still requires due process and remains subject to judicial review. Even autonomous regional assemblies cannot remove an elected presiding officer by political shortcut: when an official is stripped of office through accusations of misconduct, the body must still observe due process, allow the official […]

When Local Permits Beat National Regulators: What Cockpit Licensing Teaches Businesses About LGU Authority

National regulators cannot replace LGU permit decisions without clear control power. The ruling protects local licensing authority and business permit autonomy. Businesses operating in regulated industries cannot assume that a national agency’s approval will override a local government permit decision. In licensing disputes involving local facilities, the Supreme Court held that a national regulator’s power […]