Franchise Tax Discounts Are Not Automatic: Why Similar Businesses Are Not Always Tax Competitors

A telecom franchise holder could not claim another operator’s lower tax rate because they were not true competitors and tax reductions must be clearly granted. A company cannot reduce its franchise tax merely because another telecommunications operator enjoys a lower rate, unless the two are truly competing on equal footing and the claimed tax reduction […]

A Dismissed Criminal Case Can Come Back Before Arraignment

A pre-arraignment dismissal may still be revived: no plea means no double jeopardy, and prior preliminary investigation can satisfy due process. A criminal case dismissed before arraignment is not necessarily over. When the accused has not yet pleaded to the charge, prosecutors may still seek reconsideration, the Tanodbayan may reverse a prior recommendation to dismiss, […]

A Firearm Permit Issued by the Wrong Official Will Not Save an Illegal Possession Case

A defective firearm permit from an unauthorized official is not a defense to illegal possession; good faith cannot defeat malum prohibitum liability. A person charged with illegal possession of a firearm cannot rely on good faith, official rank, or a locally issued permit if the law requires a different approving authority. In People v. Neri, […]

When Congress Changes a Tax Franchise, Tax Exemptions Can Disappear Overnight

Franchise tax exemptions may be withdrawn by Congress, but penalties may be removed when the taxpayer’s liability was genuinely uncertain and controversial. A company operating under a legislative franchise cannot assume that an old in-lieu-of-all-taxes clause will permanently shield it from income tax. When Congress validly amends the tax law and withdraws prior franchise exemptions, […]

When Prosecutors Are Not Ready, a Dismissed Criminal Case May Become an Acquittal

A speedy-trial dismissal after prosecution delay may operate as an acquittal, barring revival of the same case in tax or regulatory prosecutions. Accused persons in criminal cases may invoke the right to speedy trial not merely to postpone proceedings, but to end them; when the prosecution repeatedly fails to appear or present evidence, a dismissal […]

Sugar Mills Cannot Use Private Contracts to Avoid Statutory Sharing of Crop Proceeds

Private sugar milling contracts cannot defeat valid social-justice regulation reallocating crop proceeds for planters and laborers in a regulated industry. Private milling contracts cannot be used to defeat a statutory social-justice scheme that reallocates crop proceeds for the benefit of agricultural producers and laborers. For sugar planters, mills, banks, and commodity businesses, the ruling is […]

When Government Safety Rules Cost Money: Why Compliance Burdens Are Not Automatically Unconstitutional

A costly safety rule is not unconstitutional merely because compliance is burdensome. The Court sustained road safety regulation as valid police power. Regulated businesses and vehicle owners cannot defeat a public safety regulation merely by arguing that compliance is inconvenient, expensive, or harsh. When the government acts under police power to prevent road accidents and […]

When a Regulatory Appeal Goes Dormant: Why Courts Will Not Decide Business Disputes After the Issue Has Disappeared

A dormant challenge to PAL’s provisional authority was dismissed after operations ceased and the petitioner failed to oppose dismissal, leaving no live controversy. A party challenging a government permit or provisional operating authority must actively preserve a live controversy. When the disputed business operation has already ended, years have passed without action, and the challenger […]

A Defective Criminal Charge Is Not Always an Acquittal

A defective criminal information may be dismissed without ending the case if there is no merits acquittal, allowing prosecutors to refile a valid charge. A criminal case dismissed because the information fails to allege an essential element of the offense is not necessarily over. Where the dismissal is not based on the merits and contains […]

Meralco’s Franchise Tax Exemption Did Not Shield Imported Equipment from Compensating Tax

Meralco’s franchise did not exempt imported equipment from compensating tax because tax exemptions must be clear and strictly construed against taxpayers. A taxpayer claiming exemption from Philippine taxes must point to clear, unmistakable language granting that privilege; broad franchise phrases such as “in lieu of all taxes” will not erase taxes that the law and […]