Tax Credits Cannot Pay Regulatory Fees Unless the Law Clearly Says So

The Supreme Court held that backpay certificates usable for taxes cannot pay motor vehicle registration fees, which are regulatory fees, not taxes. Taxpayers cannot treat every government charge as a tax simply because money is being collected by the State. Where the charge is a regulatory fee imposed under the police power, a tax credit, […]

When a Levy Is Not a Tax: Sugar Centrals Cannot Refuse a Statutory Industry Charge Because They Dislike How the Fund Is Spent

Sugar centrals must pay the PHILSUGIN levy despite alleged fund misuse; the remedy is to challenge unauthorized spending, not refuse payment. Businesses required to contribute to a statutory industry fund cannot simply stop paying because they believe the government agency is misusing the money. When the charge is imposed as part of the State’s police […]

Undisputed Evidence Can Carry a Regulated-Goods Conviction on Appeal

Unrebutted direct evidence can sustain conviction in regulated-goods cases, showing why taxpayers must answer enforcement findings early and with records. Appeals do not rescue a taxpayer, trader, or regulated-business defendant from a conviction or penalty when the government’s proof is direct, physical, and unrebutted. The practical doctrine in So Yock is simple but important: when […]