A Case Cannot Be Dismissed Before the Facts Are Heard

Courts cannot dismiss civil cases on disputed facts without hearing evidence. Borje protects litigants from premature dismissal and denial of due process. Courts cannot short-circuit a lawsuit by dismissing it on disputed factual grounds before the parties are heard. When a complaint raises factual issues requiring proof, especially where both sides disagree on what happened, […]

A Pending Motion for Reconsideration Can Stop Execution When It Is Not Merely for Delay

A proper motion for reconsideration suspends finality; courts abuse discretion by issuing execution while that motion remains unresolved. A judgment cannot be executed as final while a timely and legally sufficient motion for reconsideration remains unresolved. For litigants, this ruling protects a basic but critical right: a party who properly asks the trial court to […]

Court Filing Fees Must Follow the Assessed Value, Not a Party’s Market Estimate

Supreme Court held that real estate docket fees may follow assessed value, not alleged market value, and that compromise approval belongs to the trial court. Litigants challenging land transactions cannot inflate court filing fees by pointing to an alleged market value when the Rules of Court require computation from the property’s assessed value. For property […]

When a Court Cannot Add Interest After Judgment: The Void Execution Rule

A writ of execution cannot add legal interest when the final judgment did not award it; such excess enforcement is void and not cured by estoppel. A losing party cannot be forced to pay interest through execution if the final judgment itself did not award interest. The rule is simple but powerful: execution must follow […]

When Sharp Pleadings Become Contempt: What Tax Litigants Should Know About Courtroom Advocacy

A lawyer may challenge an unfair order, but insulting language can be contempt. The Supreme Court lifted an excessive suspension and restored rebuttal evidence. Lawyers and litigants may challenge a judge’s ruling, even forcefully, but the challenge must remain within the bounds of respect for the court. Calo v. Judge Tapucar draws the line between […]

When a New Lawful Lease Makes an Old Possession Case Moot

A later lawful lease from the property owner made an earlier possession order moot, but damages and indemnity for destroyed improvements remained payable. A party who later obtains lawful possession from the real owner of the property cannot be forced to surrender that same property merely because of an earlier possessory judgment. The practical doctrine […]

Returning to Jail Does Not Waive Your Criminal Appeal

A detained accused who returns to jail after conviction does not automatically waive appeal when a timely notice of appeal is filed within the Rules of Court period. An accused person who is taken back to jail after conviction does not automatically lose the right to appeal. Flores v. Judge Dalisay protects a basic but […]

When a Labor Case Becomes Moot, Courts Will Not Decide It Just to Settle the Argument

A labor prohibition case was dismissed as moot after the parties no longer needed a ruling on the certification election dispute. A party asking a court to stop an ongoing labor proceeding may lose the case without any ruling on the merits if later events make the dispute academic. The practical lesson is simple but […]

A Guilty Plea Cannot Shortcut a Criminal Case Without Prosecutor Notice and Consent

A judge cannot accept a guilty plea to a lesser offense without proper prosecutor notice and factual basis; the defective conviction may be reopened. A trial judge cannot quietly reduce a serious criminal prosecution by accepting a guilty plea to a lesser offense when the prosecutors are not properly notified, the evidence does not clearly […]