When a Strike Injunction Case Becomes Moot: Why Courts Will Not Decide Labor Disputes After the Controversy Has Passed

A strike injunction challenge was dismissed as moot after later events overtook the dispute, leaving no live controversy for the Supreme Court to decide. Courts do not decide labor injunction disputes merely to settle a past argument. When a strike, picketing controversy, or restraining order has lost its practical effect because later events have overtaken […]

When a Tax or Regulatory Case Becomes Moot, the Court May Refuse to Decide It

Courts may dismiss tax or regulatory challenges when later events remove the live controversy, even if the original petition questioned jurisdiction. A court case can disappear as a live controversy when the facts that made judicial relief necessary no longer exist. For taxpayers, regulated businesses, unions, employers, and officers facing government or court orders, the […]

A Missing Extension Order Will Not Automatically Kill an Appeal

The Supreme Court held that a missing extension order in the record on appeal does not automatically defeat an appeal filed within the approved extension. An appeal should not be dismissed merely because the record on appeal omits the trial court’s formal order granting an extension of time, so long as the record was in […]

The Foreclosure Value Rule: Why a Small Collection Case Can Still Belong in a Higher Court

A small debt collection case may still belong in a higher court when it also seeks foreclosure of valuable mortgaged personal property. A creditor’s case is not automatically a small money claim simply because the principal amount demanded is low. When the complaint also seeks foreclosure of a chattel mortgage, jurisdiction may turn on the […]

A Missed Pre-Trial Cannot End Your Case Unless You and Your Lawyer Were Properly Notified

A missed pre-trial cannot justify default unless both party and counsel were properly notified, preserving due process in civil and tax-related litigation. A party should not lose a case, be declared in default, or be deprived of the right to present evidence merely because only the lawyer received a pre-trial notice. The rule from Lim […]

Courts May Relax Filing Deadlines When Strict Procedure Would Defeat Substantial Justice

Courts may relax missed filing deadlines when the delay is justified, non-prejudicial, and strict procedure would defeat substantial justice. Litigants who miss a procedural deadline are not always automatically out of court. When no substantial prejudice is shown and the delay results from circumstances that make strict compliance inequitable, courts may use their inherent power […]

When a Case Becomes Moot, Courts Will Not Give Advisory Opinions

Courts will not decide moot disputes or issue advisory opinions after legal changes erase the live controversy, a rule relevant to tax and regulatory cases. Courts will not decide a dispute that has lost its practical effect, even when the original legal question was important. For taxpayers, regulated businesses, employers, and government agencies, the practical […]