Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When the Taxpayer Did Not Actually Receive the Preliminary Assessment Notice

A taxpayer defeated a Php22.5M VAT and withholding tax assessment because the BIR failed to prove actual receipt of the PAN before collection. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments may defeat collection when the Bureau of Internal Revenue cannot prove that the Preliminary Assessment Notice was actually received. For businesses assessed for VAT, withholding taxes, or […]

VAT Refund Denied After Zero-Rated Sales and Input Tax Fail Substantiation Tests

VAT refund claim denied after zero-rated sales and input taxes failed strict substantiation, foreign-currency, invoicing, and excess input VAT tests. Businesses claiming VAT refunds for zero-rated sales must be ready to prove every link in the refund chain: the customerโ€™s zero-rated status, the foreign-currency payment trail, the nature of the services rendered, the validity of […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When the Final Demand Ignores the Taxpayerโ€™s PAN Reply

Tax assessments may be void when the BIR issues a final demand that merely repeats the PAN and fails to address the taxpayerโ€™s defenses. Taxpayers who submit a timely and substantive reply to a Preliminary Assessment Notice are entitled to more than a mechanical Final Letter of Demand. When the BIR merely repeats the same […]

Criminal Tax Cases Can Still Be Dismissed When the Government Files Too Late

A criminal tax case remained dismissed after the Court held that a later DOJ tolling rule could not revive a prosecution already barred by prescription. Taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges may still invoke prescription when the government files the Information in court after the five-year period, especially where applying a later Supreme […]

Late BIR Reconsideration Fails as Deficiency Tax Assessment Cancellation Stands

A late BIR motion failed, leaving cancelled deficiency income tax assessments void where taxpayer defenses were not meaningfully considered. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments gain another important reminder from this ruling: a BIR assessment may be cancelled when the taxpayerโ€™s protest submissions are not meaningfully considered, and a late motion for reconsideration will not revive […]

Customs Smuggling Charges Fail When Prosecutors Cannot Prove Importation

The tax court acquitted an importer in a customs smuggling case after prosecutors failed to prove that the alleged cigarette shipment was actually imported. Importers and customs brokers facing criminal smuggling charges should closely examine whether the prosecution can prove the first and most basic fact: that the goods were actually imported into the Philippines. […]

Tax Refund Appeals Can Be Lost by Skipping the Required Motion for Reconsideration

A tax refund appeal was dismissed because the Commissioner skipped the required reconsideration of an amended decision that changed the refund computation. Tax refund and tax credit cases can be lost on procedure even when the underlying refund issue remains significant: a party that wants to challenge an amended decision of the Court in Division […]

Invalid Tax Waivers Can Still Defeat BIR Assessments, But Lease DST May Survive

Defective BIR waiver barred income tax, VAT, and EWT assessments; lease DST survived, while IAET and compromise penalties were cancelled for lack of basis. Taxpayers facing old BIR assessments should scrutinize every waiver of prescription, because a defective waiver can still wipe out major income tax, VAT, and withholding tax assessments even when the BIR […]

Clark Freeport PAGCOR Licensees Remain Under 5% Gross Income Tax, Not Franchise Tax

Clark Freeport PAGCOR licensees remain under the 5% gross income tax regime, not the 5% franchise tax imposed by RMC No. 32-2022. PAGCOR licensees operating inside Clark Freeport should not automatically be shifted from the 5% gross income tax regime to the 5% franchise tax merely because their revenues come from gaming operations. For registered […]

Deficiency VAT Assessment Cancelled After Reconsideration Fails to Cure Due Process and Factual Defects

The tax court denied reconsideration and kept a deficiency VAT assessment cancelled for lack of factual basis and due process defects. Taxpayers facing a deficiency VAT assessment should treat factual basis and due process objections as potentially case-ending defenses, especially where the assessment appears to be unsupported or where the sequence and service of assessment […]