Late Appeals From BIR Assessment Decisions Can Lose Before the Merits Are Heard

Taxpayers must prove the FDDA receipt date; unsupported claims and delivery estimates cannot save a late appeal from dismissal for lack of jurisdiction. Taxpayers contesting a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment must be prepared to prove when they actually received it, because an unsupported receipt date can cause the entire tax assessment appeal to be […]

Customs Forfeiture Appeals Can End Once the Commissioner Orders Release of the Seized Vessel

A customs forfeiture appeal was closed after the Commissioner reversed the forfeiture and ordered release of the tugboat, making the dispute moot. Importers, vessel operators, and customs stakeholders facing seizure or forfeiture proceedings should reassess their litigation strategy when the Bureau of Customs itself reverses the forfeiture and orders the property released, because the Court […]

BIR Withdrawal of Warrant Ends VAT Assessment Case After Due Process Challenge

A VAT assessment case ended after the BIR withdrew a collection warrant, agreed to proper service, and allowed the taxpayer to protest administratively. Taxpayers facing collection through a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy should not assume that immediate judicial litigation is the only path forward. Where the assessment documents were allegedly not properly served and […]

Condominium Associations Win Key Local Business Tax Refund Ruling in Taguig

Condominium associations are not subject to local business tax absent proof of profit-making activity beyond ordinary condominium administration. Condominium corporations facing local business tax assessments have a strong defense when the city treats association dues and ordinary condominium administration as a taxable business. For condominium associations, property managers, developers, and unit-owner boards, the ruling reinforces […]

Billion-Peso Tax Assessment Voided After Unauthorized BIR Audit and Due Process Lapses

A β‚±1.862B tax assessment was voided after the tax court found unauthorized BIR audit officers and failure to address the taxpayer’s PAN reply. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should scrutinize not only the amounts assessed, but also whether the BIR officers who conducted the audit were properly authorized and whether the final assessment actually addressed […]

VAT Zero-Rating Refunds Survive Reconsideration When Evidence and Invoicing Hold Up

Taxpayer preserved a VAT refund and tax credit win after the Court rejected repeated BIR arguments on zero-rated services and invoicing compliance. Taxpayers claiming VAT refunds or tax credits for zero-rated services can protect a favorable ruling on appeal when they prove that the services qualify under Section 108(B)(2) of the Tax Code and show […]

Taxpayers Seeking Refunds Cannot Reopen Trial After Judgment Without Compelling Grounds

Taxpayers in refund and tax credit cases must present complete evidence before judgment; the Court refused to reopen trial without compelling grounds. Taxpayers pursuing refund or tax credit cases must present their complete evidence before judgment because a later request to reopen trial will not be granted merely by invoking fairness, inadvertence, mistake, or oversight. […]

VAT Refunds for Export Service Providers Can Fail on Filing Venue and Foreign Client Status

Export service providers risk losing VAT refunds if claims are filed with the wrong BIR office or the foreign affiliate is deemed doing business locally. Export service providers claiming VAT refunds must treat procedural venue and customer status as substantive risks: filing with the wrong BIR office and failing to prove that the foreign service […]

BIR Cannot Revive a Dismissed Criminal Tax Case Without Proper OSG Authority

Tax authority’s certiorari petition was dismissed after a criminal tax case demurrer due to lack of proper OSG authority and mere evidentiary review. Government tax prosecutors cannot treat every adverse ruling in a criminal tax case as a certiorari issue. When a trial court grants a demurrer to evidence and dismisses a criminal tax prosecution, […]

Invalid BIR Assessment Service Can Defeat a Tax Collection Warrant

Tax court voided a Php105.42M income tax and VAT assessment due to improper service of final assessment notices and unauthorized revenue officers. Taxpayers facing collection based on an assessment they never properly received may still be able to challenge the BIR’s collection action, even after the agency claims the assessment has become final. In this […]