BIR Cannot Revive a Dismissed Criminal Tax Case Without Proper OSG Authority

Tax authority’s certiorari petition was dismissed after a criminal tax case demurrer due to lack of proper OSG authority and mere evidentiary review. Government tax prosecutors cannot treat every adverse ruling in a criminal tax case as a certiorari issue. When a trial court grants a demurrer to evidence and dismisses a criminal tax prosecution, […]

When a Taxpayer Must Prove Prescription in a BIR Assessment Dispute

Taxpayers must prove filing dates to invoke prescription, while the BIR must still observe Letter of Authority due process in audits. A taxpayer challenging a BIR assessment on the ground of prescription must prove when the limitation period actually began and ended; it is not enough to argue that more than three years passed from […]

VAT Refund Claims Can Fail When Foreign Client Status Is Not Proven at Trial

A VAT refund claimant lost reconsideration after failing to prove foreign clients were not doing business in the Philippines and trying to reopen trial with forgotten evidence. Taxpayers claiming VAT refunds or tax credits for zero-rated service sales must prove every legal element in court, even if the BIR partially allowed the administrative claim. A […]

Ecozone Automobile Sales Can Qualify for VAT Zero-Rating When Tied to Registered Activities

A taxpayer defeated a P81.84 million VAT assessment after the tax court upheld ecozone zero-rating and voided an unexplained input tax disallowance. Taxpayers selling goods to ecozone-registered customers should not assume that VAT zero-rating is lost merely because the items sold are automobiles or spare parts; what matters is whether the goods are used in […]

VAT Refund Claims Can Still Be Proven in the Court of Tax Appeals Even After BIR Denial

Taxpayers may prove VAT refund claims anew before the tax court if evidence is formally offered, despite a prior BIR denial of the administrative claim. Taxpayers pursuing VAT refund or tax credit claims should be prepared to prove their entitlement all over again before the Court of Tax Appeals, because the tax court may evaluate […]

VAT Refund Claims Cannot Be Defeated by Delinquency Verification Issues Alone

Tax court denied reconsideration and upheld a VAT refund, rejecting the view that DVC remarks alone invalidated the taxpayer’s administrative claim. Taxpayers pursuing VAT refunds should not be treated as having filed no administrative claim simply because the revenue authority insists on a delinquency verification certificate without adverse remarks. In this March 2025 resolution, the […]

VAT Refunds for Renewable Energy Contractors Require Project-Level BOI Proof

A VAT refund was partly granted after the taxpayer proved renewable energy zero-rated sales, but defects in input VAT documents reduced the claim. VAT refund claimants supplying services to renewable energy projects must prove not only that their sales are zero-rated, but also that the underlying renewable energy project is properly supported by the required […]

Premature Final Assessment Can Void a BIR Deficiency Tax Case

The Court denied reconsideration and sustained cancellation of BIR deficiency taxes because the final assessment was issued before the 15-day PAN reply period expired. Taxpayers who receive a Preliminary Assessment Notice must be given the full 15-day period to respond before the Bureau of Internal Revenue issues a Final Assessment Notice or Formal Letter of […]

VAT Cannot Be Added Back to Gross Receipts for Local Business Tax Assessments

VAT cannot be included in gross receipts for local business tax, and local governments must prove actual fraud to use the 10-year assessment period. Local governments assessing local business tax cannot treat VAT as part of taxable gross receipts where the Local Government Code excludes VAT from the tax base. For taxpayers facing post-audit city […]

Missed CTA E-Filing Deadlines Can Defeat a Taxpayer’s Assessment Appeal

A taxpayer lost its assessment appeal after failing to email the required PDF copy within 24 hours, making CTA e-filing compliance critical. Taxpayers challenging a denied protest before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat electronic submission as a jurisdiction-sensitive filing requirement, not as a clerical afterthought. A petition for review that is personally filed […]