BIR Tax Compromise Below 40% Approved After Taxpayer Shows Doubtful Validity of VAT Assessment

Taxpayer’s 20% compromise of a disputed VAT assessment was approved after legal and factual grounds showed doubtful validity of the BIR assessment. Taxpayers negotiating a compromise of disputed BIR assessments should not assume that a rate below 40% will be accepted merely because the Commissioner agrees. When a compromise is based on doubtful validity of […]

Taxpayers Can End VAT Assessment Litigation Through a Court-Approved Compromise

A deficiency VAT case was closed after the tax court approved a BIR compromise settlement for 25% of the basic assessment, with NEB approval. Taxpayers facing disputed deficiency VAT assessments may still resolve the case through a compromise settlement while litigation is pending, but the settlement must be properly approved, fully supported by authority documents, […]

Wrong Appeal Mode Can End a Tax Code Prosecution Before Review

A criminal tax appeal was dismissed after the prosecution filed the wrong remedy, making the RTC acquittal final and executory. Criminal tax cases decided by a Regional Trial Court require strict attention to the mode and deadline for appeal. When the prosecution chooses the wrong remedy, even a challenge to an acquittal or adverse criminal […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When Revenue Officers Lack Proper Authority or the Notice Has No Due Date

Taxpayers can defeat BIR assessments when unauthorized revenue officers conduct the audit or the final assessment notice lacks a definite due date for payment. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency assessments should closely review whether every revenue officer who participated in the audit was named in a valid Letter of Authority and whether the final assessment notice […]

VAT Refunds for ROHQ Services Can Survive Rehashed BIR Objections

Court denied the Commissioner’s MR, leaving intact a VAT refund/tax credit win involving ROHQ services and zero-rated transactions under Section 108(B)(2). Taxpayers claiming VAT refunds or tax credits should not assume that a BIR administrative denial is the end of the case, especially where the Court of Tax Appeals is presented with sufficient evidence that […]

Criminal Tax Cases Can Fail When the BIR Files Too Late or Builds on a Defective Assessment

A tax crime case for alleged failure to pay deficiency income tax was dismissed because prosecution was filed late and the assessment was defective. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should not assume that a final assessment automatically results in conviction. When the government files a tax crime case beyond the five-year prescriptive period, or when […]

Unauthorized Revenue Officers Can Void a BIR Tax Assessment

The tax court upheld cancellation of a BIR assessment after unauthorized revenue officers participated in the audit without a valid Letter of Authority. Taxpayers facing BIR assessments should closely examine whether every revenue officer who participated in the audit was covered by a valid Letter of Authority, because an assessment issued from an unauthorized investigation […]

Invalid BIR Audit Authority Can Defeat Criminal Tax Charges for Willful Failure to Pay

A tax prosecution for willful failure to pay failed because the assessment was void, notice was unproven, and the Information was filed beyond the five-year period. Corporate officers facing criminal tax charges for alleged willful failure to pay taxes cannot be convicted merely because the BIR says an assessment became final. The prosecution must still […]

VAT Refund Denied: ROHQ Must Prove Valid Foreign Currency Offsetting for Zero-Rated Service Sales

ROHQ VAT refund denied after taxpayer failed to prove a valid, traceable foreign currency offsetting arrangement for zero-rated service sales. Philippine regional operating headquarters and service exporters claiming VAT refunds must prove not only that their clients are foreign and that services were rendered from the Philippines, but also that the consideration was actually paid […]