Technical Smuggling Charges Cannot Be Split Into Multiple Customs Cases for the Same Importation

CTA dismissed a duplicate technical smuggling case involving the same import entry, holding that one alleged customs fraud cannot be split into multiple criminal charges. Importers, customs brokers, and government personnel facing technical smuggling allegations should closely examine whether multiple criminal cases are being filed from the same import entry, the same imported goods, and […]

Late Appeals from Final Tax Assessments Can Doom Collection Challenges

A taxpayer that waited after an FDDA before going to court lost its assessment appeal; the ruling warns that collection notices cannot revive expired CTA deadlines. Taxpayers who receive a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment must act quickly: a later warrant of distraint, levy, or garnishment will not restart the period to appeal. For businesses […]

Professional Partnerships Can Recover Erroneous Local Business Taxes When the Proper Refund Remedy Is Timely Filed

Professional partnerships may recover erroneous local business tax payments, but only for periods brought to court within the two-year refund deadline. Professional partnerships that pay local business tax despite being engaged purely in the practice of a regulated profession may recover the erroneous payment, but only for tax periods brought to court within the two-year […]

Airlines Seeking Excise Tax Refunds Must Prove Local Unavailability With More Than Price Lists

Airline excise tax refund denied after failure to prove imported liquor and tobacco were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit based on a statutory tax exemption must be ready to prove every factual condition of that exemption with competent, detailed, and credible evidence. For airline […]

Taxpayers Can End BIR Assessment Cases Through Court-Approved Compromise Agreements

A disputed BIR assessment was resolved through a court-approved compromise, showing how taxpayers can settle CTA tax cases without a full merits ruling. Taxpayers facing a disputed BIR assessment may avoid the cost, delay, and uncertainty of a full Court of Tax Appeals trial when the case is resolved through a properly executed compromise agreement […]

Local Tax Appeals Fail When Cities Merely Rehash Arguments on Reconsideration

A local tax motion for reconsideration failed because the city merely repeated rejected arguments and did not defend its Quezon City Revenue Code interpretation. Local governments and taxpayers litigating local tax disputes must treat a motion for reconsideration as a narrow opportunity to identify genuine legal or factual error, not as a second chance to […]

VAT Refund Appeals Can Be Lost Even Before the Merits Are Heard

A VAT refund claim was dismissed after the taxpayer missed the 90+30-day appeal period, showing why zero-rated sales refund deadlines must be monitored strictly. VAT-registered taxpayers claiming refunds for excess input VAT on zero-rated sales must treat the statutory 90-day BIR action period and the following 30-day court appeal period as jurisdictional deadlines. A request […]

Missed Appeal Deadlines Can Defeat Challenges to BIR Garnishment and Distraint

Taxpayers must appeal from the WDL, not wait for garnishment; the CTA denied reconsideration after finding the petition time-barred. Taxpayers facing BIR collection measures must act as soon as a warrant of distraint and levy is served, because waiting for a later warrant of garnishment may already be too late to bring the dispute before […]

Tax Assessments Survive Reconsideration When Service and Due Process Objections Are Rehashed

Rehashed service and due process objections failed to overturn deficiency income tax, VAT, and EWT assessments partly upheld against the taxpayer. Taxpayers disputing deficiency income tax, VAT, and withholding tax assessments cannot rely on repeated due process objections at reconsideration stage unless they present new, substantial, and legally compelling grounds. In this January 2025 resolution, […]