Taxpayers Need Not Produce Quarterly Returns to Win a CWT Refund

The Supreme Court held that quarterly ITRs are not indispensable in CWT refund claims if the taxpayer proves the statutory refund requirements. Taxpayers claiming a refund of excess creditable withholding taxes cannot be defeated by an evidentiary requirement that the tax law itself does not impose. In this ruling, the Supreme Court confirmed that a […]

RAO No. 1-2019: BIR Legal Group Reorganization Affects Tax Rulings, Protests, Refund Appeals, Tax Treaty Relief, and RATE Cases

RAO No. 1-2019 reorganized the BIR Legal Group, clarifying offices for rulings, protests, refunds, tax treaty relief, litigation, and RATE cases. Taxpayers dealing with BIR legal questions, administrative protests, refund appeals, tax treaty relief, informer’s rewards, or tax fraud prosecution must now route and frame their submissions around the reorganized Legal Group functions under RAO […]

Tax Assessments for Withholding Agents Still Prescribe: Why BIR Waivers Must Be Specific

Withholding tax assessments are internal revenue tax assessments subject to prescription; vague BIR waivers may not extend the assessment period. Withholding agents can invoke the three-year prescriptive period for tax assessments when the BIR seeks to collect alleged Expanded Withholding Tax or Withholding Tax on Compensation deficiencies. A company that signs a defective waiver does […]

Coal Operators Can Still Recover VAT Wrongly Withheld Despite Later VAT Law Amendments

Coal operators under PD 972 may recover VAT wrongly withheld because RA 9337 did not repeal special-law tax exemptions recognized by the NIRC. Coal operators with tax incentives under a valid Coal Operating Contract may still be exempt from value-added tax, and VAT wrongly withheld from their coal sales may be recovered as a refund […]

When the BIR Ignores Your Protest, the Tax Assessment Can Be Void

A BIR tax assessment may be void if the agency ignores the taxpayer’s protest, evidence, and explanations instead of giving reasoned factual and legal bases. A tax assessment is not valid simply because the BIR issued papers demanding payment. If the taxpayer answered the findings, submitted documents, and explained its side, the BIR must actually […]

RMC No. 75-2018: Letter of Authority Required Before BIR Tax Assessments and Audit Proceedings

RMC No. 75-2018 confirms that BIR assessments and audit proceedings require a valid Letter of Authority; assessments without an LOA are void. Taxpayers facing a BIR audit should immediately verify whether the revenue officer has a valid Letter of Authority before submitting to further examination or assessment proceedings. RMC No. 75-2018 confirms a critical due […]

Refund-First Irrevocability Rule: A Later Quarterly Tax Entry Does Not Automatically Defeat a Corporate Refund Claim

A taxpayer that first chose refund in its annual return was not barred by later quarterly entries showing prior-year excess credits. Corporate taxpayers that clearly choose a refund in their annual income tax return are not automatically disqualified merely because the same excess credit later appears in quarterly returns. The key lesson of the Refund-First […]

A Tax Assessment Is Void When BIR Auditors Go Beyond the Letter of Authority

BIR assessments may be void when auditors exceed the Letter of Authority, and crop-year taxpayers may deduct expenses when related crop income is realized. Taxpayers can defeat a deficiency tax assessment when BIR revenue officers assess a period not covered by their Letter of Authority, even if the BIR believes the accounting treatment was wrong. […]