Coal Operators May Still Claim VAT Exemption Under Special Laws Despite Later Tax Amendments

Special-law tax exemptions may survive later VAT amendments, allowing Semirara to recover wrongly withheld VAT despite BIR documentation objections. Coal operators covered by a valid coal operating contract may remain exempt from VAT when that exemption is granted by a special law, even if a later tax statute removes coal from the general list of […]

Tax Refunds Can Expire Even While the BIR Stays Silent

Final withholding tax refunds require both BIR and CTA filings within two years from payment; BIR inaction does not stop prescription. A taxpayer who asks the BIR for a refund cannot simply wait for the agency to act. When the two-year period is about to expire, the taxpayer must also file the case in the […]

RMO No. 6-2017: Automatic Use of Preprocessed RELIEF and BOC Third-Party Data in BIR Audits

RMO No. 6-2017 requires automatic use of preprocessed RELIEF and BOC data in eLA-covered BIR audits, raising third-party matching risks. Taxpayers under a BIR electronic Letter of Authority should expect investigating offices to automatically receive and use third-party sales, purchases, and importation data in the audit. RMO No. 6-2017 removes the need for investigating offices […]

When a Void SEC Ruling Still Cannot Cancel a Land Title Automatically

A void SEC ruling could not automatically cancel a Torrens title; parties must use the proper court action to challenge title transfers and related property rights. A void judgment creates no rights, but the party injured by it must still use the correct remedy before the correct court. For property owners, corporations, and taxpayers dealing […]

The Educational Use Doctrine: When Non-Stock Schools Can Defeat BIR Assessments on Rental Income

Non-stock, non-profit schools may exempt revenues from tax if they prove actual, direct, and exclusive educational use, even for rental income. Non-stock, non-profit schools are not automatically taxed on income from canteens, bookstores, leases, or other revenue-generating arrangements if they can prove that the money was actually, directly, and exclusively used for education. The decisive […]

Tax Deductions Fail When Receipts Do Not Match the Taxpayer

Businesses must substantiate deductions with reliable records; altered, undated, or mismatched receipts can justify disallowance and deficiency tax assessments. Businesses claiming deductions for raw materials, supplies, or other expenses must be ready to prove not only that the expenses were ordinary and necessary, but also that the documents supporting them are reliable, properly issued, and […]

Tax Deductions Fail Without Reliable Receipts: Why Business Expense Records Matter in BIR Assessments

The Supreme Court held that business deductions must be proven with credible records; defective receipts can justify BIR disallowance and tax liability. Businesses cannot defeat a BIR deficiency assessment by merely saying an expense was ordinary, necessary, and actually incurred. When a taxpayer claims deductions, it must be ready to prove them with credible records; […]

When a Share Redemption Is Not a Taxable Dividend

Share redemption premiums are not automatically dividends. The Court allowed Goodyear’s refund and held no 15% FWT applied without unrestricted retained earnings. Companies that redeem shares from a foreign shareholder do not automatically owe dividend withholding tax merely because the redemption price exceeds par value. The controlling question is whether the payment is truly a […]

Share Redemptions Are Not Automatically Dividends: When Foreign Parent Companies Can Claim Tax Refunds in the Philippines

Share redemption proceeds paid to a US parent were not taxable dividends because Goodyear had no unrestricted retained earnings, supporting a P14.66M tax refund. A Philippine company that redeems shares held by a foreign parent does not automatically create taxable dividend income merely because the redemption price exceeds par value. If the payment is not […]