When a Judge Asks for Money: Why Court Corruption Can Destroy a Case and a Career

A judge who solicits money for a favorable court decision may be dismissed, while accusations against other judges still require substantial evidence. Litigants who are asked by a judge, court employee, or intermediary to pay money for a favorable decision are not dealing with a lawful litigation expense; they are facing judicial corruption that can […]

When a Judge Refuses an Arrest Warrant, the Real Question Is Bad Faith — Not Mere Disagreement

Judges may refuse arrest warrants absent probable cause without discipline, but may be reprimanded for leaving motions unresolved for months. Prosecutors, complainants, and accused persons cannot treat every unfavorable court order as judicial misconduct. A judge who refuses to issue an arrest warrant because probable cause has not been established is not administratively liable merely […]

Search Warrants for Tax Violations Require More Than Unpaid Purchase Prices

Judges must find probable cause for the specific tax offense charged before issuing a search warrant; non-payment alone cannot justify seizure. Tax-related search warrants cannot rest on a bare allegation that someone failed to pay for imported goods, duties, or taxes; a judge must personally determine probable cause for the specific tax or customs offense […]

When Tax Credits Become Refundable: The Fairness Rule in Philippine Tax Refund Claims

Corporations may recover excess withholding tax when records show the credit was never used, despite procedural defects in proving the refund claim. A taxpayer that overpays income tax is not automatically barred from getting a refund simply because it initially failed to present every document at the tax court level. When the record later clearly […]

Security Agencies Cannot Deduct Guard Salaries from Contractor’s Tax Gross Receipts

Security agencies cannot deduct guard salaries and statutory contributions from contractor’s tax gross receipts; late protests can make BIR assessments final. Security agencies must treat the full amounts they receive from clients as taxable gross receipts for contractor’s tax purposes, even when much of those collections are later used to pay guards’ salaries, SSS, Medicare, […]

When Retained Earnings Become Taxable: The Cyanamid Rule on Improperly Accumulated Profits

Cyanamid confirms that retained earnings may be taxed when a corporation cannot prove they are needed for immediate, reasonable business purposes. Corporations that keep profits inside the company instead of declaring dividends may be taxed if they cannot prove that the retained earnings are needed for the immediate and reasonable needs of the business. The […]

When Retained Earnings Become Taxable: The Working Capital Test for Corporate Surplus

Companies retaining large profits must prove genuine working capital needs or risk accumulated earnings tax, even if wholly owned by a foreign parent. Corporations cannot defeat the accumulated earnings tax merely by saying that retained profits are needed as working capital. When a company keeps profits instead of distributing dividends, it must be ready to […]

When Retained Earnings Become Taxable: The Business-Need Rule for Philippine Corporations

Cyanamid clarifies that retained earnings must be proven necessary for business needs, or corporations may face improperly accumulated earnings tax after a BIR assessment. Corporations that keep profits instead of declaring dividends cannot rely on broad claims of “working capital” to avoid the improperly accumulated earnings tax. The controlling lesson of Cyanamid Philippines is practical […]

RMO No. 87-99: BIR No-Appeal Recommendations Must Reach the Commissioner Within 10 or 15 Days After Adverse Court Decisions

RMO No. 87-99 sets 10-day and 15-day BIR deadlines for no-appeal recommendations from adverse court decisions, affecting tax litigation strategy. BIR offices handling tax litigation must act quickly when they intend to recommend no further appeal from an adverse court decision: recommendations for cases handled by the National Office must reach the Office of the […]